Quote:
|
It seems to me that Kath was more interested in finding out Roa's identity than weather or not she was a wolf faithful.
|
Because I did not believe she was a wolf faithful, I believed she was the Cobbler. In the post I made outlining what I thought were the possibilities surrounding what was going on, the one in which Roa turned out to be the Cobbler was the one I was most in support of. The only worry I had was the fact that in previous games the Cobbler could not be seen by the Seer, and then Mac clarified that in fact they could be seen in this game so I left my vote as it was.
Today we are rid of the Cobbler and we have a known innocent who, if the Ranger can still protect him toNight, will be a help to us both toDay and the next, and since we've lost three ordo's in the space of two Days we really do need to get a Faithful toDay.
TGWBS suggests a shortlist. This early on I'm not sure I agree. With 15 people left the chance that we get a shortlist entirely composed of innocents, or worse Gifteds, is very high. But perhaps we could do something similar. If we each choose the person we are most suspicious of, along with an actual text-based explaining the reasons why, and then take the three most suspicious people and allow Nogrod to decide which should be lynched. It's entirely unfoolproof as of course the wolves will be able to see who is in the running, but at least the decision isn't as arbitrary as a simple shortlist. Again though we could get a list of innocents.
Umm, Gil, the wolves didn't kill Glirdan. He 'committed suicide' because he hadn't voted two Day's running.
I think ... I think Mith is innocent. I've just read Durelin's suspicions of her and I can't share them. I don't think a wolvish (or a Gifted for that matter) Mith would draw such attention to herself. I think her frenzied attempt to save Roa was down to worry over the numbers. To me this makes Durelin look somewhat suspicious. Quoting Mith's worries about being lynched for 'supporting' Roa yesterDay and then proceeding to suspect her for that reason would be a wonderful bluff, and I can quite see Durelin as a bold enough wolf to try that.
I wish we could hear more from Lommy. Her lack of posts has been explained but I find it hard to get a feel from her when she isn't happily flood-posting the thread!
That's all my ideas for the moment, at least the ones willing to form an orderly queue and go down on the page. I'll be around for a while yet though.