Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Manwe
Seeing as no-one else spotted the mistake yesterday. Those two posts [227, 235] you point out were me in fact me advocating strongly for the death of Roa. I was trying to get across to you that your reservations for voting Roa were incorrect, that killing Roa was the best option. Others have also stated that this was the best option.
|
You're mixing up the two issues. Though I regard voting for Roa as a Faithful thing to do, others find it sensible. This issue divides innocents, as Nogrod and Rikae showed.
You, however, thought it was sensible to kill Roa not because you wanted to be rid of the cobbler, but because you entertained the notion that she might not be the cobbler. This doubt of Rikae looks very faithful to me, especially the way you tried to make it look widespread in post 203 when it wasn't:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Manwe, post203
I would also like to add, that Roa seems to have lost her 'cool' after the accusation. Seems rather desperate; now we have Rikae a possible Seer (possible in the eyes of Roa and a few others) revealing her as the cobbler.
|
Post 227 and 235 are devoted to doubting Rikae's claim to be the Seer:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Manwe, post 227
People, what Rikae says is why I wrote my second 'plus' for killing Roa, if we kill Roa and she is innocent we know that Rikae is lying without doubt. Rikae telling us Roa is the Cobbler is a perfect chance to sort the mess out of, is she (Roa) a Cobbler, and is she (Rikae) the Seer.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Manwe, post 235
Killing Roa and finding out what she is would prove without doubt whether Rikae is the Seer or not. It's a win win situation in a way, for if Rikae is not a Seer than we can kill her, with a certain knowledge she is either the actual Cobbler or Faithful thats if she does not die tonight.
|
Please do not try to confuse the two issues of voting for Roa, and believing Roa's claim that Rikae was not the Seer. The two are very different, and your willingness to muddle them to make my accusations look unsound only further cement my belief in your guilt.
I also note the knee-jerk reaction.
Quote:
|
You seem intent on having me lynched.
|
All too true.
On a non-Manwe note, the Faithfuls' killing of Rune has confused me. Why kill the person who gained the second-most votes, who could most likely be lynched today?
One theory is that there are a few wolves among the Brinniel voters who feared suspicion and so killed Rune, thereby showing that most of the rest of the village had also voted for an innocent yesterday. This would incriminate Lalaith, Legate, Lommy and Mith. But the more I think about it, the less this kill makes sense.