Oh, I see,
Gil's come and voted again...
Well, that argument of
Durelin's and
Nogrod's is something quite weird...
While I give credit to
Nogrod's theory (and to his
logic 
) I think he's a bit harsh there. I certainly would not be surprised to find
TGWBS and
Durelin wolves - I've suspected them from quite early - and
Sauce isn't the most innocent-looking of villagers either (so all in all
Nog's theory is a good one), but I think
Nog has got a bit too enthusiastic about his theory: I think he's reading a bit too much to
Durelin's responses. (Yes, believe it or not, I'm defending one of my main suspects here.
)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Durelin
Considering the number of people, including myself, who have not even had a vote for them yet, I'd say there are quite a few who could fall under the "haven't really gotten suspicion" category.
|
"Haven't been suspected" and "haven't been voted" are different things my dear friend... You know it as well as I do. But why try to say something like that? To shadow the points and to stick to interpretating words in a convenient way to you? |
I think this is a good example of it. I got the impression
Durelin used the voting-thing to demonstrate the not many have really been suspected -argument, while
Nogrod draws equation marks between
Durelin saying "not really suspected" and "not voted". Overall
Durelin's responses seem a bit edgy, which might point to a nervous wolf, but it's worth keeping in mind that an innocent may turn quite edgy too while facing that kind of consistent attack. And no, this little defense of
Durelin does not mean that I'd suspect her any less than I did before, merely that
Nogrod's a bit too enthusiastic about his case and I'm not sure if all his points concluded form his and
Durelin's dialogue are valid. So, my thoughts:
Nogrod's case - very good;
Durelin - suspicious; the points
Nogrod has against
Durelin in their dialogue - partly good, pertly bad.
I'd love to do an analysis of
TGWBS before I go, but as it took quite a long time to do the
Durelin-one, I'm not sure if I have time...