++TGWBS
His case against me was ill-constructed.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by he
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by me
I agree with them we shouldn't speculate them too much [about roles]
|
Isn't that what Roa, who she defends, was doing? |
I was not defending
Roa in general, and that should be easy to see. I said I found nothing wrong with her points. I didn't say that role talk is suspicious. If I had said so, I'd definitely be flip-floppery. But I said we shouldn't specualte about them too much, meaning that it's a secondary thing and gets the attention away from the important. Also, he deliberatedly seems to misinterpret
Roa by saying she says gifteds shouldn't reveal. Furthermore, like
Roa pointed out, he says that gifted-talk is no way helpful, but continues it himself. He seems very edgy/jumpy too.
And the worst crime, he's a conservatist...
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by TGWBS
I am suspicious of Thinlomien for a number of factors. Observe-ye:
. . .
4. Tradition!
|