[Nogrod]

I don't know what to say of Roa's little analysis... funny perhaps is the right word? But it also make me a bit more worried about Roa.

So why?

Firstly: The main argument seems to be that I waffle and am not decisve. I myself am more than suspicious of people who are very decisive on Day1's. Being decisive this early normally means that one has some knowledge we others don't have. Or that it's a wolf who tries to cover her/his tracks in a monomania.

Secondly: It looks like it is just a bit too fabricated. As I've said before, I know Roa to be an extremely good player and she really has an evil eye with her summarisings / analyses. But this is just not the quality I've used to. And even though I know she loves to show how good she is in making damning analyses, as a villager she would in the end wish to help us others and not try to artifically make points from where there are none.

Just a few corrections.

I'm a wolf because I didn't want to lynch tgwbs yesterDay? Now that would be quite stupid from a wolf-Noggie. Were he a wolf it would have been my best choice as it would look pretty good in my voting record and were he not I would have gotten rid of a formidable enemy quite easily leaving no suspicious tracks behind.

I brought Mac up because I thought he was acting suspiciously. That happened late in the game, not on the early stages. You can't suspect someone's actions before they act... Mac's early posting looked okay, his late posting didn't.

Why I was suddenly ready to go for Glirdy? Simply because it was a choice between him and Lommy. Both were shots in the dark for me, but I believe Lommy can make a difference if innocent - and she had acted reasonably, unlike Glirdy who had acted suspiciously.

Xyzzy then? Maybe all of you who make your points about that affair should read what was said about lynching him yesterDay once more before you continue? Mith suggested the "cynical idea" based on the possibility that he will not join the game in the first place (it would not have been the first time when a first-timer doesn't show up). I thought it worth considering as Mith said he had been online on Saturday the last time. I voiced my concern that there is a possibility he could show up on some phase of the game and then it would be cruel (although I don't know how long one could be allowed to not appear just because they are newbies). After Brinn told us about the birthday stuff, I decided not to pursue that track anymore.