My brain hurts.
While I ponder, I'll just say that I was pretty certain Macalaure had some absolutely fiendish and brilliant plot to squeeze the remaining vampire's identity from me. I had no idea why he would give me a kill. I killed Nogrod because, well, does it matter? He could theoretically have taken out another innocent and thus increased Gil's chances of winning by a slight percentage.
It was an interesting game but kind of depressing from our point of view because we realised very early that we had little chance of winning. Villagers did well though.
(We said bad things about you, Kitanna.
)