[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

It might be safe to assume at least to begin with that the one (or more) who killed Menel were goodies.

Maybe. I'm remembering in the last game I modded that one of my wolves killed the other the first night. While that doesn't seem to apply to this game (the bad guys can seemingly converse), it's possible (I think) that there can be different 'breeds' of bad guys that might not know each others' identities. Menel could have been an accident, he could have been strategic (a decoy, or a martyr)...

So we could have goodies that can kill. But the two others then? The easy answer is that we have wolves and the werebear.

So what exactly is a were-bear? And has 'thief' ever been used as a role before?

Originally Posted by Morm

Trust me or not I do not care but Mith is innocent I tell you. Now on to Fea another one I can read a bit better than most

I agree about Mith. I'm curious what you'll have to say about me, since I've been unhelpful and distant (unavoidable) thus far. You really can read me better than most. It's a lovely change from the people who find me inscrutable.

Originally Posted by 6th Wizard

Nogrod: Seems a bit jumpy. I don't think he's himself.

I agree he seems jumpy. I disagree that he doesn't seem like himself. He merits watching as a general thing, but at the moment, he doesn't concern me much. To me, he's the sort wherein if we leave him around, he'll be as helpful as he always is, but if it gets to a point near the end where he is a bad guy, he'll probably give himself away. I'm vaguely certain that he's someone we ought to keep around for a while. We can always kill him later, but we can't always replace his helpful activity.

[QUOTE=Mormegil[b]]++Kath

[/b]Kath is Kath and generally I'm happier if she is simply dead, plus she deserves it.[/QUOTE]

Hilarious and probably true. I've missed working 'with' you guys.

Originally Posted by Lommy

Fea's posts seem quite self-centered and that makes me slightly uneasy. But otherwise she seems quite innocent so I'm not too worried about her.

Don't worry, hunny, I'm always self-centered.