The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale

Aganzir · 06-05-2007, 04:04 PM

Day 1
#37: Supports lynching someone about who one can't form a picture, if one has no (good) reason to lynch a loud player / a contributor. Says that even though Nogrod was hasty about Shasta, it wouldn't be nice to lose him (Nog). Rikae seems innocent. No clear opinion about Menel due to his spelling, which always turns ignore-function on in her brain. Durelin makes her wonder. Boro is giving bad vibes, but she doesn't want to lynch him. Shasta, Sixth and Kath are normal, xyzzy a little suspicious. Nothing to say about Isabell.

#44: Doesn't believe the evil team would consist only of three wolves and the cobbler. The only ones she suspects even a little are Boro and xyzzy, but she doesn't want to vote Boro and doesn't like the idea of voting xyzzy either.

#47: Says she won't vote now but will ask if Noggie or I could post her vote later, if she wants to vote.

#50: Says she's leaving.

Day 2
#156: Thinks an Assassin or a Bear killed Menel, the wolves Rune, and Durelin was killed because of doing something. Is slightly annoyed by Volo's new playing style, which would give him a perfect cover and make it harder for others to figure out anything about him. Not too worried about Fea, not much wary of Boro anymore. Tgwbs innocentish. Legate doesn't sit right with her, and resembles a bit wolf-Legate. Mith makes her uneasy. Kath seems odd, maybe a Bear? Volo's playing style worries her. Nogrod could be either way. Morm is weird. Shasta mildly suspicious. Izzie's vote wolfish, but she might be a puzzled newbie as well. Sixth seems normal. Aganzir makes her slightly uneasy. Rikae seems pretty innocent, but has been somewhat shady.
Has no idea who to vote, suspects too many people.

#157: Meditates on what should be done with Gil. If he was to be lynched, he should be lynched soon. But lynching him might prove fatal with such a big number of nightly kills.

#158: Votes Kath. Posts a quote that she says looks like Kath were the bear, and says her usually helpful tone seems somewhat forced this time, and innocent Kath usually gives better grounds to her suspicions.

#159: There are more cons than pros to lynching Gil, as he might start playing more actively.

Day 3
#253: Says she was slightly surprised by Nightly kills and wonders who was killed by whom. Thinks someone should probably go through Legate's posts, and says she'd do it herself but it takes time and she should probably let Noggie log in and comment something. Says she might do it later though.

#256: Kath was probably some sort of a cobbler, who maybe knew the wolves' identities. Kath's posts should be examined very carefully, if at all, for they could mislead us a lot.

#259: Asks Volo if he has dropped his eccentric style.

#261: Asks Volo if Kath didn't suspect Noggie as well.

#268: Banter.

#269: Says we can't assume the wolves killed Legate because he was getting too close, as we don't know if it were wolves who killed him. Doesn't know if the idea of two rival wolf teams (about 2 wolves / team) should be dropped yet.

#271: Says she's going to sleep.

#288: Says she has suspected Volo a little, but thinks now he's on the innocent side. Thinks that it would be very unfair if the wolves could win as separate groups. Says tgwbs is a bit too quick to jump to conclusions on the quiet/loud issue; Rune's death doesn't necessarily point to silent wolves and Menel's to loud wolves. Finds tgwbs (maybe evilly) hasty, but he looks rather innocent.

#309: Says it would be nice if Volo gave grounds to his ideas. Thinks Sixth is actually quite suspicious. Has mixed feelings about Isabell, and could lynch either of them. Mith feels sincere yet somewhat suspiciously non-committal, but she's growing gradually less suspicious of her. Is growing wary of morm. Gil's absence bugs her, but killing him would probably be a waste of lynch.

All this, and the result is: I still have no idea. I have not played much with her, and not at once with a wolf-Lommy (unless she is now), so I don't know how she's like when a wolf (and stalking doesn't count - do you think I have paid attention to your playing style if I haven't been playing myself?).

Actually the first thing that caught my eye was that she didn't have an opinion about Menel because his spelling turned the ignore-function on in her brain - but that feels like a very vague reason to suspect her.
And now it seems to me that it's the only reason I could have if I wanted to keep suspecting her. I fail to find anything wolfish (or worth mentioning) from these posts. Either she's innocent or completely fooling me.

Deadline is in half an hour, and even if I could hope to find anything, I'd rather leave it for now. Argh, my head is exploding.

06-05-2007, 04:04 PM	#342
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	Lommy Day 1 #37: Supports lynching someone about who one can't form a picture, if one has no (good) reason to lynch a loud player / a contributor. Says that even though Nogrod was hasty about Shasta, it wouldn't be nice to lose him (Nog). Rikae seems innocent. No clear opinion about Menel due to his spelling, which always turns ignore-function on in her brain. Durelin makes her wonder. Boro is giving bad vibes, but she doesn't want to lynch him. Shasta, Sixth and Kath are normal, xyzzy a little suspicious. Nothing to say about Isabell. #44: Doesn't believe the evil team would consist only of three wolves and the cobbler. The only ones she suspects even a little are Boro and xyzzy, but she doesn't want to vote Boro and doesn't like the idea of voting xyzzy either. #47: Says she won't vote now but will ask if Noggie or I could post her vote later, if she wants to vote. #50: Says she's leaving. Day 2 #156: Thinks an Assassin or a Bear killed Menel, the wolves Rune, and Durelin was killed because of doing something. Is slightly annoyed by Volo's new playing style, which would give him a perfect cover and make it harder for others to figure out anything about him. Not too worried about Fea, not much wary of Boro anymore. Tgwbs innocentish. Legate doesn't sit right with her, and resembles a bit wolf-Legate. Mith makes her uneasy. Kath seems odd, maybe a Bear? Volo's playing style worries her. Nogrod could be either way. Morm is weird. Shasta mildly suspicious. Izzie's vote wolfish, but she might be a puzzled newbie as well. Sixth seems normal. Aganzir makes her slightly uneasy. Rikae seems pretty innocent, but has been somewhat shady. Has no idea who to vote, suspects too many people. #157: Meditates on what should be done with Gil. If he was to be lynched, he should be lynched soon. But lynching him might prove fatal with such a big number of nightly kills. #158: Votes Kath. Posts a quote that she says looks like Kath were the bear, and says her usually helpful tone seems somewhat forced this time, and innocent Kath usually gives better grounds to her suspicions. #159: There are more cons than pros to lynching Gil, as he might start playing more actively. Day 3 #253: Says she was slightly surprised by Nightly kills and wonders who was killed by whom. Thinks someone should probably go through Legate's posts, and says she'd do it herself but it takes time and she should probably let Noggie log in and comment something. Says she might do it later though. #256: Kath was probably some sort of a cobbler, who maybe knew the wolves' identities. Kath's posts should be examined very carefully, if at all, for they could mislead us a lot. #259: Asks Volo if he has dropped his eccentric style. #261: Asks Volo if Kath didn't suspect Noggie as well. #268: Banter. #269: Says we can't assume the wolves killed Legate because he was getting too close, as we don't know if it were wolves who killed him. Doesn't know if the idea of two rival wolf teams (about 2 wolves / team) should be dropped yet. #271: Says she's going to sleep. #288: Says she has suspected Volo a little, but thinks now he's on the innocent side. Thinks that it would be very unfair if the wolves could win as separate groups. Says tgwbs is a bit too quick to jump to conclusions on the quiet/loud issue; Rune's death doesn't necessarily point to silent wolves and Menel's to loud wolves. Finds tgwbs (maybe evilly) hasty, but he looks rather innocent. #309: Says it would be nice if Volo gave grounds to his ideas. Thinks Sixth is actually quite suspicious. Has mixed feelings about Isabell, and could lynch either of them. Mith feels sincere yet somewhat suspiciously non-committal, but she's growing gradually less suspicious of her. Is growing wary of morm. Gil's absence bugs her, but killing him would probably be a waste of lynch. All this, and the result is: I still have no idea. I have not played much with her, and not at once with a wolf-Lommy (unless she is now), so I don't know how she's like when a wolf (and stalking doesn't count - do you think I have paid attention to your playing style if I haven't been playing myself?). Actually the first thing that caught my eye was that she didn't have an opinion about Menel because his spelling turned the ignore-function on in her brain - but that feels like a very vague reason to suspect her. And now it seems to me that it's the only reason I could have if I wanted to keep suspecting her. I fail to find anything wolfish (or worth mentioning) from these posts. Either she's innocent or completely fooling me. Deadline is in half an hour, and even if I could hope to find anything, I'd rather leave it for now. Argh, my head is exploding. __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle.