Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Bęthberry
So, I named a person from this forum who has garnered accolade after accolade for the quality of his fanfiction, the mighty Mithadan, whose Tol Eressëa
stories were held to be the highest and finest attempt to capture the elusive elements of Tolkien's writing. (I won't say anything about his REB fanfic, because he was positively scandalous there.)
|
And its very good....yet, a line of Aneurin's came to mind as I read, an elegy for one of the men of Gododdin who fell at Catraeth:
'He glutted black ravens on the walls, but he was no Arthur.' I don't want to sound too negative - I was impressed, yet some things jarred ("Pengolodh
snorted"
)