[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Izzy is likely innocent. We don't think Nogrod would have risked building a case against a fellow wolf so early and so consistently.

SPM is perhaps innocent. We think that if SPM & Nogrod were wolf allies then they would have made more of their traditional arguments. Instead we see them extending hands of friendship. Nogrod clearly wanted to be friends with SPM. He was, though, stabbed in the back somewhat.

Kath is probably innocent. Nogrod places her at the top of his suspect list for no apparent reason, seeming to exaggerate his views from #34 to #37.

Durelin is in his "some concerns" category partly because he was swayed by Rikae's comment on her posts. We think this makes Durelin look slightly guilty, because he is keeping her near the top of his suspect. Also, he doesn't want anything she might have done to slide by unnoticed and without criticism, because he doesn't want to be allied with her. So he disagrees with Rikae's criticism but still decides to give Rikae the benefit of the doubt; and is happy to put Durelin near the top of his list, without any real reason.

We are thinking that, if there are 2 other wolves, Nogrod would not place them on the same level of suspicion. So, let us consider Nogrod's "slightly worried about" category (#37), which is: SPM, Brinniel, Rikae and Menel. We think there is one wolf among them, and we consider SPM the least suspicious of those.

So: right now we think Durelin looks quite guilty, and with her probably Menel or Brinniel.

Rikae is perhaps less suspicious if Durelin is a wolf, because both Rikae and Nogrod debated reasons against Durelin.

So that's what we think right now. The Warriors of Finn have spoken. Heed their words.