I must say you all have me sick to death of these 'if this, then that' arguments. There is absolutely no way for you to prove the premise 'if so-and-so is/isn't a wolf, then so-and-so #2 isn't/is a wolf', so give up trying to sound logical. This is 'Werewolf'.
Wow, I feel like
TGWBS...
*snort* While you guys are pouring over
Nogrod's-specially-encoded-list-positionings, I will be clutching at some at least more realistic straws.
I have a bad feeling about
Rikae and
Isabell.
Rikae's "if
Brinniel, then not
Espiem, but if not
Brinniel then
Espiem" bothers me, but what bothers me even more is her "let's get to the bottom of this", as if we are all on the same page, we've explored every other avenue, this is our only lead, this is the last piece of the puzzle...or something.
Eh? I mean, I don't feel like
Brinniel is innocent, and I am definitely not loving
Espiem right now, but...whatever.
Isabell's kind neutrality puts me off. But this particular thing bothers the heck out of me:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Isabell
After looking through a couple of Nogrod’s posts more finely, I definitely must laugh. He seemed to be pointing a direct arrow at himself, saying, “I AM A WOLF, VOTE FOR ME NOW.” Particularly when he said that Caomerilin looked more innocentish after having voted for him. As well as kind of not having a firm pointing finger of suspicion when it came to everyone else. Save for myself and Kath. I get the feeling that since I do not talk as much as others, (mainly due to time zone) that I end up being a pick for scapegoating.. an easy vote, with which the wolves can attempt to make a ‘case’ for and try to lobby others to follow suite. :P
|
Yes, the whole thing. Look at it! It's an entire paragraph dedicated to a 'laughing off' sort of defense of her being a Wolf on
Nogrod's list, explaining why he would pick her to be one of his top suspects. Uh...
Nogrod's dead, we all know he was a Wolf...why so worried? Obviously at the top of a Wolf's suspect list is not where most people are looking for another Wolf.
However, I see that as entirely possible...so maybe your seemingly off-handed, 'oh, how funny' defense is preemptive but genuine and practical?
*wanders off to raise her bloodsugar*