Quote:
Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc
I think Sauron's personality stored in the Ring will gnaw its way through and could lead Galadriel to do some of these stereotypical evil things. Against her own, albeit tyrannic wishes, to be absolutely clear.
|
My feeling is that while the Ring may contain some of Sauron's Will, it doesn't contain so much of his 'taste' that it will make a possessor of it ever want to live in a big tower in a blasted landscape - unless that desire was there in the first place. I think a 'megaLorien' is at the same 'extreme' of evil as Mordor - both are 'effects' of the utilisation of absolute power.
In short, while the Mordorisation of M-e is uglier than the Lorienisation of M-e, it isn't more 'evil' (unless judged purely aesthetically). Or in other words, Mordorisation is not the 'final step' beyond Lorienisation - the latter is equally an 'ultimate' manifestation of evil, & would equally demonstrate the absolute victory of the Ring.