Quote:
Originally Posted by MatthewM
You are never going to win this battle, defending the films against the books so irriationally. Say all you want about your cinderblocks. You are wrong. The book always rules out the movies. They are not supposed to be two different things, they are both "The Lord of the Rings" and the way that PJ chose to portray certain characters and events counter to the book does not rest well with the true Tolkien enthusiast, except for you and a small majority.
|
You've made Sauron the White's point rather well, and just when I was hoping that he was coming over to the Books side.
Read the SbS to see my scene by scene criticisms regarding Peter Jackson's work where I quibbled on most everything; yet in all of that I hope to never ever to be on 'your' side as it's been the Movie-lovers' points of view that have extended my appreciation for both the movies and books.
Quote:
|
And alatar...I'm disappointed in you.
|
Why? I never knew that you appointed me...
