|
Hardy and strong does not equal training for ultra marathon distances - not once, not twice but on three consecutive days.
We will agree to disagree then.
Again, aside from the running, my main point was that many Tolkien book purists will go to the nth degree with all type of intellectual exercies and rationalizations to attempt to prove that the book is perfect and no errors or holes are in it. I think this discussion shows that beyond any shadow of a doubt. But it is our willing suspension of disbelief that helps us accept the improbable or even the impossible.
All I am asking for is the same willing suspension of disbelief when it comes to the films. What is good for the goose should be good for the gander. Someone should go back and read the first page and one-half of the thread DENETHORS PLUNGE and the mocking ridicule heaped upon the films by many here. The films seem to be fair game --- but heaven help anyone who raises a question about the books being inconsistent.
That is all I was trying to say from the beginning this subject came up.
|