[Guildo]

I Still dont think you understand what im trying to say Sal.

If you have Good you MUST, MUST, MUST have an Evil.(period)

If you question that, your questioning a big part of the laws of physics. (For more information see Thermodynamics, study Quantum physics, read a Stephen Hawking Book, for for a spiritual point of view research Budism, and the Yin & Yang theory)

When Iluvitar first came to be he/she was niether Good nor Bad, more like a nuetral but not even that, because there was nothing to contrast him/her.

But when he/she created Melkor(a Bad) Goodness was defined as Iluvitar.

The Most Practical Example i can think of is- If you have spent your entire life in Darkness (True Black Darkness), and no one has ever described "Light" to you, you would have no reckoning of what "light" is untill it could be seen through your eyes.

Iluvitar created Melkor to make himself known as Good.As well as the stuff ive previously said.

/\
/ \
/ \
do your
worst.