My thoughts on you others come here. I only had time to reread yesterDay's posts, though.
Innocentish
Volo - He makes sense. I think he raises arguments a wolf wouldn't raise and his tone and suspicions seem genuine.
Macalaure - Quite often (or almost always) when he's a wolf he seems somewhat tense and un-relaxed and there's something edgy in his manner. All that is missing this time. If Rikae proves to be a wolf, I'd be quite confident he's innocent: she treats him like she would not treat a fellow wolf. (No time to elaborate on that right now. I'll do it later, if Rikae proves to be a wolf.)
Farael - Reasonable and innocently calm, raises good points and jokes in an innocentish manner. Right now, I have no reason to be troubled by him.
A tiny bit innocent-ish
Legate of Amon Lanc - There's nothing in his posts that seems particularly suspicious to me. His relaxed, calm and somewhat joking manner seems quite genuinely innocentish. Why he doesn't belong to the "innocentish" category, though, is that I have a nagging bad feeling that he really isn't as innocent as he seems.
Shastanis Althreduin - Now there is definitely not much to go on, but I doubt he would be that uninvolved as a wolf. There's nothing that'd make my wolf-spotting radar beep in his posts or manner. I think I need to see more of his posts to be surer, though.
Gray zone
Feanor of the Peredhil - There really isn't much to go on. She seems somehwat distant, playful and rational all the same time and I really can't say anything about her before she makes the post about her feelings she promised to make.
Aganzir - Generally, she feels quite rational and sincere, but she makes some vague comments like "Considering Valier herself, she looks quite neutral to me. However, if a certain person(s) turned out to be a wolf, I'd look at her very carefully" and odd comments like that I seem to be protecting and warning Greenie.
Meneltarmacil - He seems quite sincere and doesn't send out the wolvish vibe he usually does as a wolf. On the other hand, I really don't like he repeatedly talks about the wolves eating him. If he had said it once, I would have no issue with it, but twice and with such an overreacting tone is a bit too much for me to overlook.
Kath - Otherwise, she seems and feels innocentish, but I really don't like her yesterday's vote. It seems a bit forced.
Slightly suspicious
Satansaloser2005 - Now, she seems be just joke and be in-character while making a few serious points, just enough to maintain a presence. I don't like some of her comments like "By the way, great posts today!". I don't know, I really can't reason this very much but I have a slight bad feeling about her: I'll be watching her more closely.
Brinniel - Her first post still strikes me as wolvish. Her other posts could be either way.
The Might - The more I think of it, the less I like his self-vote. It seems like something he would have done as a wolf (since Rikae did it as an innocent in the last game). Also, his notable lack of suspicions seems a bit wolvish too - of course it's difficult for a wolf to come up with suspicions and newbie wolves often make the mistake here. All in all, I'm not very convinced of his guilt, though. He needs to be watched.
Kuruharan - He has chosen a playing style that is very convenient for a wolf. There's something suspicious in his overall tone and I can't really see why did he vote Nerwen, not me, yesterDay. There was no threat of a double-lynch in the air anymore when he voted, or so I see it.
Suspicious
Mormegil - Everything that I've said of him and Valier's death. His manner is somewhat suspicious as well (but I don't know if anyone should take that as a serious argument from me as I always seem to find his manner suspicious).
A Little Green - Like I said, I don't like the tone of her first few posts and her latest seemed quite wolvish. There's something very fishy in her overall manner.
It is quite useless to read and make conclusions of Rikae's posts as her role is to be revealed soon.
EDIT: xed with Agan
__________________
Like the stars chase the sun, over the glowing hill I will conquer
Blood is running deep, some things never sleep Double Fenris
|