The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - WW XXXX

Brinniel · 12-06-2007, 02:37 AM

I wonder if the wolves actually killed Kath because they thought she was the seer. I honestly didn't see anything seerish about her before...and there were others who looked more seerish than her. She wasn't generally suspected, so that could be a reason why they chose her...

Who she could've dreamt of:

Night 1
My best guess is Lommy. She found her innocent all three Days and as a louder player, Lommy would be a good Night 1 choice.

Night 2
This is the one I'm struggling on; I think she either dreamt of Might or Green.

Might would seem like the obvious choice. After all, she voted for him the previous Day. And why not vote for your top suspect? If she did dream of him, then Might would be guilty because she never did drop her suspicions. But then, why did she not pursue him? Was she worried her seerishness would be too obvious to the wolves? Was it because Might wasn't heavily suspected the next two Days?

It's also possible she dreamt of Green since from the first post, she began suspecting her. Still, I'm not sure. Why would she dream of Green? Why would she keep Might on her most suspicious list for three Days and not dream him?

Night 3
I'm quite sure she dreamt of morm. Her thoughts on him changed overnight even when he was still a top suspect.

My guess is that she dreamt of Menel last Night. Too bad we won't ever know. Here's another thought: Why did she suspect Menel in the first place? Might was still higher on her suspicious list when she started to suspect Menel. She was the first to vote Menel; my guess is that she chose him because he was more likely to receive votes, and she knew how important it was to save morm.

I still would like to consider it a possibility Kath dreamt of Might. I think perhaps we should look at the connections between Green and Might, Green and Menel, and Might and Menel.

It's a shame both of our gifteds had to leave so early before deadline. I'm sure if morm knew for sure he couldn't be saved, he would've revealed. And if Kath were around, she probably would've revealed him too if she indeed dreamt of him.

12-06-2007, 02:37 AM	#459
Brinniel Reflection of Darkness Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Polishing the stars. Well, somebody has to do it; they're looking a little bit dull. Posts: 2,983	I wonder if the wolves actually killed Kath because they thought she was the seer. I honestly didn't see anything seerish about her before...and there were others who looked more seerish than her. She wasn't generally suspected, so that could be a reason why they chose her... Who she could've dreamt of: Night 1 My best guess is Lommy. She found her innocent all three Days and as a louder player, Lommy would be a good Night 1 choice. Night 2 This is the one I'm struggling on; I think she either dreamt of Might or Green. Might would seem like the obvious choice. After all, she voted for him the previous Day. And why not vote for your top suspect? If she did dream of him, then Might would be guilty because she never did drop her suspicions. But then, why did she not pursue him? Was she worried her seerishness would be too obvious to the wolves? Was it because Might wasn't heavily suspected the next two Days? It's also possible she dreamt of Green since from the first post, she began suspecting her. Still, I'm not sure. Why would she dream of Green? Why would she keep Might on her most suspicious list for three Days and not dream him? Night 3 I'm quite sure she dreamt of morm. Her thoughts on him changed overnight even when he was still a top suspect. My guess is that she dreamt of Menel last Night. Too bad we won't ever know. Here's another thought: Why did she suspect Menel in the first place? Might was still higher on her suspicious list when she started to suspect Menel. She was the first to vote Menel; my guess is that she chose him because he was more likely to receive votes, and she knew how important it was to save morm. I still would like to consider it a possibility Kath dreamt of Might. I think perhaps we should look at the connections between Green and Might, Green and Menel, and Might and Menel. It's a shame both of our gifteds had to leave so early before deadline. I'm sure if morm knew for sure he couldn't be saved, he would've revealed. And if Kath were around, she probably would've revealed him too if she indeed dreamt of him. __________________ Nolite te bastardes carborundorum