Argh. I'm quite hopeless and tired and wouldn't really mind being dead so I wouldn't need to try to make anything of all of this confusing stuff and try to force my brain to think who's wolf and who's not. But, on the other hand, I really wouldn't like to die now after being this wrong about everyone. I mean, I would hardly be content with myself after a game in which I had seriously suspected one wolf and three innocents.
So, no worries, I think I'm getting over this useless pessimism and trying to hunt some wolves.
Feelings based on a reread:
Aganzir - Seems both suspicious and genuine. I realised I really can't ever read her, which is quite depressing. I'm a bit worried that no one has really paid her much attention during the whole game. I think her posts seem slightly more Pinnocent than guilty, but I have a feeling she's (again) fooling me and laughing evilly. Argh, I really don't know.
Meneltarmacil - He said (in post #149): "However, the last Night's activities do cast doubt on a morm-wolf scenario, so caution is necessary. Mostly, I just wanted to talk here so as not to be too silent. Talking often is always a good idea." Which made me raise my eyebrows. Why on earth would someone think or act like that? His thinking seems a bit too formulaic to be innocent. I mean, he keeps making assuptions like "at least one Nerwen-voter was probably a wolf" and "there are probably 1-2 quiet wolves". I don't like it. Also, his tone seems occasionally unbelievably unsincere, like in post
158. On the other hand, since Sally was an innocent, his post
301 looks quite innocent to me. But I still suspect him.
Volo - I can't see what's so suspicious with him. I think he seems innocent.
Macalaure - One big ARGH. Could be anything. Seems genuine but has had wolvish suspicions. I really have no clue what he is and I'm a bit worried that he's slipping under my radar for it has never happened before. But, if I had to bet, I'd still say he's innocent. Anyway,
Mac, please post more!
The Might - is plain confusing.
Feanor of the Peredhil - A real enigma. I think her interactions with
Greenie and her defense of
morm look slightly suspicious, though. Reading what she said about
morm, I think it looks like she decided to defend
morm quite forcefully, because she knew he was innocent and she'd look good for defending him. On the other hand, she doesn't feel particularly wolvish and I feel my suspicions of her are all too futile to be considered seriously even by myself.
Brinniel - Seems wolvish, after all. Her first post, like I've said numerous times before, looks like one of a wolf. She agrees with everybody all the time and keeps changing her opinions in a fishy way. All in all, her posts look like doing what is the most clever thing to do in each situation and thus quite ungenuine. Also, her analysis floods are all quite indecisive. She's more vocal than usually, though, and I find it slightly improbable she would be if she was a wolf: I mean, as a wolf, I - at least - find it more difficult to come up with anything to say. But she still seems suspicious to me.
Farael – He seems very genuine and innocentish to me. The only thing I'm worried about is that no one's suspecting him and if he was a wolf, he'd really pass unnoticed...
Shastanis Althreduin – See what I said about him just a while ago. I still think that way.
Kuruharan - I really can't read him. I only feel that it'd be comnvenient of a wolf to adopt such a 100% against double-lynchings attitude.
I'm just afraid I'm trying to make things more complicated than they are and that yesterDay's disaster has caused me to be too wary of my own feelings and points. I like neither of the facts. I'm just not sure if I can trust my own reasoning and I'm afraid simple solutions aren't the correct ones.
A few more things:
I think
ALG would have suspected at least one fellow wolf of hers, which leads me to believe that either
Menel or
Volo is a wolf. And
Menel looks more wolvish of the two.
I wondered about
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Fea
Kath – I know I should be terrified of you, but I'm not. Why? What are you doing differently? What am I doing differently? There's something wrong here! Just to be clear: I feel like I should be suspicious because I'm always suspicious of Kath just like (and because of the same game) how I'm suspicious all the time of morm. Just to be very clear: I really have no leanings on Kath. I'd like to see more posts from her, though.
|
and
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Fea
They thought Kath was a seer. Everybody else acted like I suspected normal villagers to act. She was quieter in a way that I'm not used to from her unless she's trying to avoid negative attention. She's a gutsier wolf, so when I scanned the villagers for who might be leaving us clues (or trying not to at first)... Shoot. This isn't making as much sense as I'd like and I'm running late. Basically, I think she was viewed as a seer not because of what she had to say, but because of how she was saying it. And I think at least one of the wolves must have played with Kath enough to know her styles. Or they just got mad lucky.
|
Usch. I really don't know what to think of this. First she notes
Kath is being unnormal, then she says a wolf probably knew
Kath's playing style and realised she was unnormal...
If
Brinn and
Menel are both wolves, hats off to them because they're doing a convincing job of looking wolvish but not looking like fellows.
Brinn and
Agan, on the other hand, could very well be fellows, based on the way how they interact. But
Brinn and
Menel, they're such enigmas. They both seem very wolvish but have innocent streaks of behaviour as well and they hardly can be both wolves. So, there's probably at least two wolves I've not paid enough attention to.
Please,
Might, please stop being confusing and start talking more about your own suspicions. Otherwise my head is going to explode.
Lastly, I'd like to point out that the wolves are getting a bigger part of our village Day by Day. Soon they will be bold enough to form alliances and vote together or manipulate the village ruthlessly. We should be careful.
EDIT: xed with everything since my last post