Quote:
Originally Posted by Sauron the White
Are we saying that JRRT was beyond the powers of every other individual who lived in that regard? In the past I have criticized some here who seem to take an almost reverential attitutde or religious fervor regarding JRRT - and now this seems to partially support that suspicion.
Is it possible that someone could improve upon JRRT works? Yes. He was a man - a human being. He was not one of his gods.
|
Well no, he was not 'one of his gods', he was
The God of all of his creation because it wouldn't have existed without him
Anything at all, whatsoever, to do with Middle-earth cannot exist without him having dreamt it up and written it down. It is logically impossible that anything to do with it could be done better by anyone else.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Aganzir
I like the Hobbit the way it is, but I've always felt some kind of distance to it- how it portrays the elves, for example. As I don't wait much from the movie anyway, I'm curious to see what they could do to the elves. I find this actually a bit strange, as in the Lotr films I practically hated everything they had changed / tried to make better.
Though it will surely be interesting to see how all those movie elf fans, many of whom haven't read the books, react if the elves suddenly change from something like Bloom-Legolas & Tyler-Arwen to those funny, cheerful creatures as in the Hobbit.
|
I'd feel disappointed if they tried to do po-faced Rings/Sil style Elves instead of the lovely yet quite dangerous creatures we see in The Hobbit. These, of all Tolkien's portrayals of Elves, come closest to Faerie...mysterious creatures who live amongst the trees in the dark forest and singing, joyful mountain Elves. Much more fun, more scary, and more interesting, than the Noldorin types to my mind