Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Kath
Lommy as Seer ~ it just doesn't look believable. She was quiet after Nog's revelation and then suddenly pops up with this.
|
Kath. Two hours before
Nog "came out" I went to sleep and said that I'll be away for a long time, possibly for as much as 15 hours. When
Nogrod made his "revelation" it was almost 1am our time, my computer was off and I was soundly asleep and I only saw his posts many hours later. That is why I didn't come out earlier.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Kath
There have been suggestions that we lynch either Nog or Lommy but I really don't want to do that. If we lynch Nog and he takes down Lommy then we lose two toDay and one toNight, with 2/3 of those being innocents. If we lynch Lommy and she really is the Seer we lose a Gifted and with so many wolves I don't think we can afford to do that.
So I basically want to ignore those two until we see the outcome of toNight.
|
The outcome won't tell anything. You will only hear that I'm dead and
Nogrod will claim I was a wolf and you haven't gained proof of anything, only lost a Defender. Don't you see that? Or, from another point of view: even if I was a wolf and
Nogrod was a guardian, my death wouldn't help you at all. You wouldn't still know if you can trust
Nogrod or not. Thereby it's utter folly to leave me to be killed by
Nogrod and his fellows: not only because you'll lose a Defender, but also because my death won't tell you anything.
That post of yours made me immediately suspect you
Kath. That ill-reasoned suggestion sounds like the talk of a wolf or a cobbler.
If we lynch
Nogrod and he is a wolf, someone of us (not necessarily anyone that can be trusted though) will know his role and can tell it. We will get rid of a wolf.
If we lynch
Nogrod and he is a guardian like he claims, he will take me with him and that action itself will prove his innocence and my guilt. We will get rid of a wolf.
If we lynched me, someone of us will know that I truly was a Defender and that
Nogrod was a wolf. We won't get rid of a wolf.
If we lynched me and I was a wolf, someone would be informed of that too and we'd get rid of a wolf.
See?
We should get rid of this lying and confusion-causing
Noggiewolf, and rather sooner than later. Even for you who cannot know the facts, lynching him toDay is the surest option.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Agan
No, that's not what I think, and don't twist my words. I was speaking about what kind of impression I got from your posts, and that impression includes the idea that you thought like that.
|
I never twist words intentionally. I did not understand you meant that, because, to put it bluntly, you phrased it quite unclearly then. And if you got that kind of impression from my posts, well, you're quite quick to jump to conclusions. Wolfishly quick?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Aganzir
I'm actually rather interested to see whom Lommy would like us to look at.
|
Ok. Other opinions? I'm quite torn whether I should reveal it or not, because with bad luck I'm exposing a gifted and with good luck it's a wolf... Should we take chances?
edit: xed with Sally and THE Ka