[Farrehn]

All those I have met really hate the slimy little stinker, Gollum. But for some strange reason, I thought he was pretty cool. Though if I was in the position of Frodo or Bilbo, I have to say both! If I were in Bilbo's position, I would have killed him. Now don't get me wrong, I like the little creep and I have an extremely compassionate heart, especially for those in need. But freom a defensive standpoint, as in Bilbo's position, i think it would have been a wiser choice to kill a viper, before it turns and bites your heel. At that point, Gollum was seaking Bilbo and the Ring out to take back his Preciouse. . . and I doubt Gollum would have showed Bilbo any compassion, seeing as he was going to get the Ring so he could come and kill Bilbo. That is why I would have killed him in that situation.
But with Frodo, it would be quite different. Frodo knew the effects of the Ring, and out of anyone, could help Gollum the best. Before,. Bilbo did not know or could have done anything to help Gollum, save to end his misery. But Frodo was the master of the Ring, or at least it's bearer, and Gollum was proving himself helpless and in need of someone to rescue him. Gollum, when Frodo had him, was willing to help, and in the movie was actually turning out far better than before! If only Frodo would have kept Gollum's trust, then Im sure he would have come back. Besides, Frodo needed to believe he could forget the Ring, and return to a semi-normal life. So yeah, that's what I would have done. . . gee, sorry it's so long! [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img]