I’ve ending up analysing
Menel in more detail than
Durelin, because there’s more to go on (whereas she seems to be trying to be as vague as possible).
Day 1.
#20. Says
Lommy is provoking
Gwath and “casting suspicion on him for no good reason”. Makes prediction: he will suspect
Boro who will prove innocent.
#23. Says
Lommy is “jokingly casting suspicion” on
Gwath. Says this is a wolf-tactic.
#33. (I think replying to
Boro’s comment about
Lommy’s playing style) “To be honest, I believe people have their own styles of playing and tend to use them regardless of their roles. I honestly don't think we can find a wolf by playing style here, and I would doubt that
Lommy actually plays differently based on her role.”
To quote myself on the same Day (#59):
Quote:
|
looks to me like he's saying, "See? I didn't jump on Boro's suggestions at all!"
|
Says his comment on
Boro was because
Boro has usually been innocent when he suspected him.
#43. Is (quite reasonably, I think) puzzled by
Mac jumping on
Nogrod’s line about “protecting our assets”.
#72. Doesn’t know why
Mac thought
Nogrod’s line worth mentioning; doesn’t know what to make of
McCaber.
#101.
Lommy and
Mac are odd; suspects
Mac more. Doesn’t suspect
Gwath. Votes
Mac (gives no reason).
Day 2.
#179. Suspects
Mac and
McCaber.
#189. Agrees with
Boro that
Mith is suspicious. Votes
McCaber on the grounds that he voted
Gwath on such weak reasons.
Day 3.
#289. Says the “Caberwagon” will probably shed light on who the wolves are. Sees
Nogrod, Volo and
Mac as suspicious.
#291. Finds
Nogrod’s analysis of me “revealing” and goes on to theorize that
Mac and I are wolves together.
#302. Says I’m “trying to ‘suspect’
Mac while absolving him of guilt at the same time. (For the record: I'm not– I'm just trying to think it out.)
General comments: veering around like a weathervane, and seems willing to suspect whoever the last poster did. But is he a wolf trying to play safe, or just a bewildered innocent? I could read it either way.
EDIT: X'd with
Mac and
Greenie.
EDIT 2: fixed tags.