I think
Nogrod should definitely play both, Gimli and Bilbo (unless we have people left who don't get to play anybody). He's doing them both magnificent, and the two characters interact only very little.
Lommy and
Lily made a quite marvellous Merry and Pippin. The only slight problem I had was telling the two apart.
You have rather similar voices, I have to say.
Nogrod, I think the music is excellent, too (definitely not too gloomy for this scene), but don't you think it's a little too loud? I had problems understanding your voice now and then.
I'm looking forward to finally hearing
Nerwen, and also very much to
Volo's version of Gandalf and more of
Legate. I'm soon (using a very loose definition of "soon" here) going to send a few more takes of mine. I had a cold recently and my voice went bad, but now I'm ok again.