Okay, since I have neither the time (it would take many hours and the deadline for today is less than two away) nor the energy to do a comprehensive analysis of everyone, I can't really make a fair case for or against anyone. (Where's the fun in fairness, anyhow?) So here's a slipshod, ambivalent, touchy-feely list of my vague opinions and baseless assumptions about the village.
Greenie -- massive echoing blank here. I can't remember anything about her.
Shasta -- As I said, I'll be watching him. He's a cheerful killer.
Isabellkaya -- has posted very little, has said nothing original or interesting, yet without being as refreshingly forthright about it as yours truly. Hmm. I've never played with her before so I don't know her habits, but this is making me think that getting rid of her would be no great loss.
Lommy -- smooth operator. Wouldn't be surprised if she were rotten to the core.
Nilp -- well if he had any special role he probably wouldn't have forget that it was Day 1. Just sayin.
Eönwë -- the fact that there are two Eonwe's blows my mind. I've played with the one who's played before, and spent all game assuming it was him, now that I know differently, I don't really know that I can make any assumptions about him at all.
Kath -- her page by page recaps make me want to lynch her just to stop her from posting them. Besides, I know how effortlessly evil she can be.
Sally -- Never played with her before, but I like her. She makes me laugh.
Mac-Daddy -- Oh come on, we all know he applied to be a wizard. The man's a born leader, I've modded a game where he was a werecreature, and played with him as one, he is so on my possible wizard list. But IS he actually one? Don't know.
Rikae -- Mommy! Are those wizard robes I see in your closet? I think you applied, anyway.
the phantom -- amuses me.
Cailín -- eeeeeeeeevil. She had made all up on her side yesterday (well, seeing as I didn't actually have time to read the thread, technically she had me on her side during the night while I read it over.) I really started to think that I'd voted for a wolf by luck of the draw (sparing phantom by voting for the next in line) but then she proved innocent and it makes Cailin look bad.
Lhunardawen -- I think Lhuna's innocent. I'm not getting any whiffs of angst or guilt off of her, and I know she doesn't like being evil, so I'm thinking she's alright. Let's lynch her, she's too nice and isn't contributing to my desire for a mass fight-a-thon.
Durelin -- Dury/Durie/Durinator. Not sure what's going on there, but she corrects peoples's word usage. If only she'd be more nasty about it and not back down.
Roa -- It would be funny if she were the EW again. Ha. But really, the insight she brings (has brought) is valuable. My own insight from the former DW game reminds me that nobody assassinates an innocent quite like Roa (she eviscerated my posts in the game, if I hadn't known better I'd have thought I was a wolf) so her gigantic sprawling case against Phantom contains whiffs of evil. I like it, has a nice odor.
Brinn -- Overly thoughtful.
Legate -- Sneaky. Complains about long posts while writing a long post, oh ho ho, that's like me complaining about lack of substance in any one of my posts.
Lalaith -- lalaith is right, she's laughing at US ALL behind that quiet exterior. I'm getting "evil" vibes due to the overall lack of whiffiness either way.
Aganzir -- Eh. I don't know.
The Ka -- I like.
morm -- Wait, he's playing in this game??
Celuien -- see morm
Gwathagor -- Beats me.
McCaber -- If Cailin is evil SO IS HE.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I pity anyone who actually read all that.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Truthfully, since allegiances are constantly changing in this game, all analysis of previous days will ultimately be moot and a big chunkalicious waste of time. IF you're looking for wolves. It's only a viable way to spend you're day if you're looking for the only two players who are never going to change, ever. The Wizards.
Personally, I think that phantom is one of the Wizards. He probably bribed Nogrod with promises of Cornhuskers paraphernalia if he made him a Wizard. Let's lynch him an find out!
By the by, I don't think it's all that harmful to talk about who you think the wizards are. Whoever they are, they're both smart and capable players, otherwise Nogrod wouldn't have entrusted the wizard roles to them. So they are more than perfectly capable to figure who are likely wizards, themselves. I'm not going to worry that my rantings and babblings and speculations are going to influence them either way.