Quote:
Originally Posted by mormegil
I hope I didn't miss anybody.
|
Me, at least.
Quote:
Originally Posted by the phantom
And come on people, where are your lists?
It's not that hard.
Just list the living players (besides Rik and I) and say what you think of them. Even one word would do (eg "Werewolf" or "Ordo").
|
If this is so, my list could suffice to you, because I really am not in the situation, nor have the time, to elaborate in much depths. But I also at least formed myself a complete list of players all at once. Here it goes:
More or less the ladder is made from the most innocent-looking to the most suspicious, even in the order inside the separate zones (green zone: innocentish; yellow zone: some ordinary fella with whom I don't feel anything bad, but also I am not just as ready to use the word "innocent" for him; orange zone: wary of; red zone: very bad). Even as I wrote it, I rearranged it on several places (switched positions), so there are sometimes mentioned things which are in the text later (but there's a link to them).
GREEN ZONE:
the phantom - I am gonna believe him. If he was sinister, he would have been stopped. That's about it.
Lalaith - especially after yesterDay, my views on her are very positive. Inclined to think innocent.
Nilpaurion Felagund - feels good, just overall. It's true maybe there is not that much from him to judge that well, but as far as I can tell, nothing particularly suspicious strikes me about him. It is worth mentioning, though, that I haven't played with him this far (so I think), so I may be off-track.
YELLOW ZONE:
Satansaloser 2005 - my love is of course innocent. No, no, not necessarily, but I think overall she is fine; I could as well put her into the green zone.
Brinniel - seems okay, rational, or definitely seemed so at the beginning (cf. my analysis on, what it was, Day 2 - it was
after I did the analysis, not before...); I think in her case, her skepticism, when there is any, is honest. And now, especially after I saw the latter posts of her, my feelings on her are pretty good.
Durelin - she seemed quite well and reasonable this far, also, as I said, she would seem more chaotic evil if she were so.
Gwathagor - something like Shasta (see below), although not so horribly misguided-looking, just Gwathagorish. Overall, I think he's more reasonable and actually may be pretty innocent.
Shastanis Althreduin - I feel rather good about him, although from some of his opinions or ideas I get the feeling that he is a horribly misguided ordo (like for example yesterDay, and even toDay, wondering about Rikae, wondering about me, about phantom...). But as you see: Yellow zone.
A Little Green - she could be either way, and I know she would be capable of disguising herself well, being a Wolf, however, I have nothing to base suspicion for her on at the time.
Isabellkya - I remember at least in the beginning there used to be good points from her, and even now, her style seems more like innocentish. The only reason why I am putting her in the yellow zone, and so deep, and not in the green zone is gut feeling. But that's about it and it may be ignored - in that case, green zone.
Celuien - Such a. Person. (cf. below the orange zone people) I have better idea about her than about those below, at least more than Kath, of whom I really have NO idea at all. Overall my feelings on her are quite mixed.
ORANGE ZONE:
Mormegil - he would be better, if it were only for some helpfulness or trying to help he presents. But. The way he acts, seldom appearing, with some sort of aggressiv-ish tone in his posts makes me worried about him. However, heck, I should say here too that his later posts, if I try to imagine him as innocent, do not seem that bad and could rather make me think better about him. But, what I wrote, I wrote. This is the way it is now.
(I see the rest of this zone is formed out of people who are totally submerged submarines. This is probably the best place to put them.)
Eönwë - such a person exists? Though I remember him saying some things, which unnerved me a bit...
McCaber - I know such a person exists, but 0+0=0
Kath - such a person....?!?!???
RED ZONE:
Lhunardawen - something seems wrong with her. Her posts, it seems like she's hiding something, or hiding from something, or whatever. Also I don't recall exactly what now, but her stances towards some problems just made me worried. But still, she is on the border, almost in the orange zone, but I wanted to underline the difference.
Roa_Aoife - eee, don't like Mommy at all. I know she tries to bring things, questions, thoughts that appear reasonable, but in my opinion, she is not so. And after yesterDay and toDay, after she kept questioning everything, and voted me, and overall seemed just wrong in her post to that point that I don't think she could have been mislead. She's clever, after all. Simply put, I would not expect her vote for me so easily had she been innocent. That's actually it, and I can generalise a little: most of the people from now on are those who are skeptic, yes, well, nothing wrong on that - but they are skeptic towards the one side, but not as much towards the other! I.e. what I said, Roa skeptically questions phantom, but does not bother questioning her own vote for me at all.
Thinlómien - I said that all before many times. My view of the story: From the beginning an ordo, later scried for a wolf, now still seeming to be undecisive about things, TOO skeptical (again, cf. above) for her skepticism to be actually honest! She may be skeptic, but heck, there is a limit!!!
INFRARED ZONE:
Rikae
Missed anyone? Hope not.
P.S. And I am aware of the fact that at the moment I make a list, I start to be totally off...
P.P.S. And I am probably going to part with you for now. Will probably show up later only to review what happened, maybe post something really, really short and then vote. I am parting with you with the signature line:
"How troublesome..."