View Single Post
Old 06-09-2008, 08:02 AM   #1103
Kath
Everlasting Whiteness
 
Kath's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams
Posts: 4,533
Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.Kath is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.
Send a message via MSN to Kath
Do you know I once made a list somewhere, possibly in the Grimoire, on how many posts I tend to make during a game. That was because I'd just experienced the same situation, where everyone kept asking me why or mentioning that I was quieter than usual. I'm not really complaining, just mentioning, because I'm not quieter than usual, I am as quiet as I usually am, just in a game this size it feels like I'm saying less.

Anyway, phantom asked for a list (I read through and had exactly the same reaction as a few others when he posted those orders, but the fact that he actually noticed this and altered it to a question made me smile) so I'll do one. Don't know if there's much point now he's revealed and voted Nilp but oh well.

Greenie - I've not been suspicious of her so haven't looked at her in any great detail.

Shasta - like many have said, he's gone unnoticed, or not unnoticed but more just there, like a noise you've stopped hearing it's so constant. That sounds really insulting, it's not meant to be, I just can't think of a better analogy.

Izzy - hmm, I see Roa's point too about going after phantom yet voting Roa with little reasoning. Over the Days when I've seen a post from her I've often re-read it or double checked it, maybe I'm seeing something there that feels wrong. Not sure.

Lommy - I don't usually have such a problem with Lommy! If she's around and noisy she's generally innocent, if she's a wolf the stress of lying tends to come across. This game ... maybe it's the number of people thing again, she's hardly quiet but seems to be being drowned out. Some have said the way she reacts to things is overly confused and so suspicious, I actually don't think so. There was a point where I thought maybe she was suspicious but when I went back and read over some of her posts I thought her innocent. That change of mind hasn't changed back since.

Nilp - well, he has been playing less ... insanely than normal, and I'm quite inclined to take phantom's word for it so, wolf.

Eonwe - ha, yelled at phantom. Yeah, that's it, that's all I recall from him. Completely under the radar. Very overwhelmed innocent or very overwhelmed wolf, very little chance of working out which.

Sally - I'm so glad she's in this village, yeah that mad posting increases the amount of time it takes to read but it's so funny. I disagree with her about the whole how much people post thing, though I would, but I don't think it makes her suspicious. I don't think a wolf could post that much without letting something slip.

Rikae - I love how she's been posting toDay! She's evil as anything but the Rocky Horror references and the sheer fun she's having make her posts a joy to read.

phantom - as I said earlier, I'm inclined to trust him. My rebellious side has had it's workout since day 1 (oh that's no typo with the small letter D, I mean from day 1 of being on the 'Downs) so it's quite happy to listen to him now, even if it does like to mutter mutinously from time to time.

Lhuna - surprisingly I have no view on her, I thought I did. I think I found her suspicious early on, a bit over the top with some reactions to things others said. I don't think I've seen enough from her since then to do anything with that opinion.

Durelin - considering she's been around a fair bit I haven't thought much of her since that spat with Agan finished.

Roa - I'm inclined to think innocent. Arguing with phantom and getting completely over the top-ly cross is Roa's usual way of playing these games. All that stuff about 'when I was the EW' helps too. I mean yes she could be evil and saying it to avoid suspicion, but I'm not sure the amount of attention it's brought her would have been worth it.

Brinn - every now and then I read a post of hers and go 'ah! suspicious' and then I re-read it and can't work out why. This happened more at the beginning of the game so maybe I just got used to it or she calmed down some or something happened. I actually wouldn't be surprised if she was a non-original wolf I think, because that might explain that slight change in style over the Days.

Legate - again, since his argumentative phase I haven't thought a huge amount about him. But then even when I did I couldn't get a clear view.

Lalaith - first I thought 'flying under the radar', then I thought 'wolf!' but I cannot remember why. That was sometime on Day 2 I think but I do remember the thought striking me quite hard, so I'll remain wary here.

morm - been quieter than you have I? Hardly an unusual occurrence. That said, you've not been so verbose yourself. This could explain why I currently have no suspicions of you, which is practically unheard of.

Celuien - I have no idea, I really don't. I read her posts, they look fine to me, then I wonder if they look too fine. It's all a big mess in my head at this point.

Gwath - bit reactionary, but on the whole seems to post sensibly and with thought. Don't know what that says about his moral compass.

McCaber - another of these I've barely noticed. There really are too many people in this game, it's making me feel bad that I've concentrated on barely a third of them when reading through.

Anyway, there's my list. It was done without looking back over the Days, I wanted to see what I thought of people when their latest post wasn't in my head or when I'd just read over an analysis of them or something. Not sure it worked too well because of the number of people I couldn't remember much about but oh well.
__________________
“If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”
Kath is offline   Reply With Quote