I do agree with your interpretation of the turn-around with
Kitanna,
Shasta. And I might be dropping my case against her at the moment as
Dury voted for
Kit on Day 1 and then on Day3 thought her innocent because she voted for Nerwen on Day1. That could be enough and we might think she probably dreamt of
Kitanna on her first Night of dreaming. But why did she say then in the beginning of Day3 that she wished to look more closely at
Kitanna,
Eönwë,
Mith &
The Ka? And why was her only defence of her innocence the fact she voted for
Nerwen on Day1?
I'm not too sure we can wash
Kitanna free with this evidence... but why does
Shasta wish to make us think like that, overdoing
Dury's "release" of
Kitanna which is doubtful in the first place when one watches the evidence. She thought her innocent along with
Rikae,
Aganzir and
Boro because of their votes. She didn't say she was especially innocent - on the contrary she said
Rikae looked the most innocent of the four...
The next thing I'd like to bring forwards is this (nothing to do with
Dury's status as the seer I guess but we might think this a good advice as we now know she was innocent and thence wasn't pulling our legs)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Dury
Mith, Ka, and Formendacil all seemed to have avoided talking about Nerwen at all, really.
|
Exactly. I'm still thinking
Mith is a wolf and
The Ka might be one as well - or then
Form but somehow I'm feeling he's not a wolf.
Dury's post #298 is really a baffling experience. Here it is in it's entirety:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Dury
Alright, some conclusions from my ramblings:
Vaguely in order of suspicion (vaguely because I am incredibly indecisive):
Shasta
Mith
Sally
Eomer
Nogrod
Aganzir makes good points about Nilp I guess, but I'm just not feeling it.
I really like Shasta right now, with his arguing of principles and such, which is why I think he might well be a wolf.
Mith and Sally feel slippery. It seems like they're trying to be...nice.
Eomer bothers me. He's channeling phantom-ness.
It just seems so right for Nogrod to be a wolf right now.
Sally - Eonwe seems cheesy...he seems to me like he's trying too hard to be surprised at things, to be interested in things, to look like he's doing something...you know, bad acting.
|
Now
Shasta is her top suspect but still she thinks she likes him "right now" and thence he must be a wolf! Is this the seer notice? Making a kind of contradictory statement to make us realise she points to him? Anyway there seems to be no easy hints in her posting... So maybe this is a more cryptic way of doing it?
In the end she was ready to vote for either
Shasta or
Mith. Now that paraphrasing leads one to wonder whether she had dreamt of neither even if she voted for
Mith (whom I believe is a wolf) in the end.
It is just too cryptic as adding my latest deductions she should have voted for
Shasta.... (so there goeas my theory)
Or then she was more careful we think she was but got bad luck being killed even if there was no point in her suspicions... Somehow I just can't believe it fully...
Edit: Corrected a host of typos & added the last sentence