The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLIX

the phantom · 08-20-2008, 11:29 AM

Rats! I've lost my business partner!

Okay Mith, as far as your idea about lynching her... hmm....

On one hand I can't imagine that she's gifted, so lynching her would ensure that we didn't have a complete Day 1 disaster.

On the other hand we will lose a chance to catch a baddie.

Now, earlier I said that the goal of a Cobbler is to die during the day, and we have a greater chance of hitting a Cobbler than a Gifted or WW. But that said, lynching a Cobbler today would not be a victory for them as compared to lynching Kitanna, for the loss of Kitanna is already a guarantee! She's going to die. And therefore lynching a Cobbler when a death is already in the bag would surely be a loss for the evil team.

So all in all I think we might want to try our luck and lynch someone else.

08-20-2008, 11:29 AM	#85
the phantom Beloved Shadow Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: The Stadium Posts: 5,971	Rats! I've lost my business partner! Okay Mith, as far as your idea about lynching her... hmm.... On one hand I can't imagine that she's gifted, so lynching her would ensure that we didn't have a complete Day 1 disaster. On the other hand we will lose a chance to catch a baddie. Now, earlier I said that the goal of a Cobbler is to die during the day, and we have a greater chance of hitting a Cobbler than a Gifted or WW. But that said, lynching a Cobbler today would not be a victory for them as compared to lynching Kitanna, for the loss of Kitanna is already a guarantee! She's going to die. And therefore lynching a Cobbler when a death is already in the bag would surely be a loss for the evil team. So all in all I think we might want to try our luck and lynch someone else. __________________ the phantom has posted. This thread is now important.