So here comes a quick look on the villagers.
Fea - A difficult case. I'm a bit uneasy about her at the moment.
Shasta - Sleeping under my reindeer.
Form - Torn about him, too. I think the cobbler assassin would have tried him last Night, unless s/he had someone s/he suspected even more. In this light I think it more probable that he is not a cobbler, but then his style of posting (see his first toDay!) seems deliberately confusing and weird and careless and rings all cobbler bells. He might even be a very bold wolf, actually.. See what a plan! Behaving so cobblerishly that the village decides to leave him for the assassin, who can't harm him since he's really a wolf! Just suggesting... I've never played with him before (?) so I can't compare his behaviour to what he usually is like.
Eönwë - Seems innocent.
Nerwen - Innocentish as well, and besides, she's a sharp player that notices things that others don't, and she really is an asset to the village if she isn't a baddie.
Kath - No read.
Nilp - Can't say. Could be anything.
Dury - I think she looks pretty innocent.
Nog's theory of her being a cobbler is interesting but I don't buy it. (And besides, I still have this bad habit of trusting people who agree with me..)
Brinn - On Day 1, I was quite convinced of her innocence. The further the game goes, the less certain I am. I still don't suspect her, really - I'm just not so sure of her innocence as I was.
Nog - Actually, I think he might be a cobbler (or even a wolf or an ordo..
) - not because of that Wittgenstein stuff, but because of his manner of trying to look helpful, especially with his analysis of
Dury.
Greenie - Me! I'm not a wolf nor a cobbler. I know.
the phantom - I think he's just annoyed to be an ordo and has a need to be important in some other way than through an important role. I don't shut out the possibility of him being a cobbler, but I don't think he's a wolf.
Lommy - Seems innocent.
EDIT: x-ed with Ëonwë - yay, so there is someone else around! *waves happily*