|
Things Brinn said yesterDay:
She stated that the CoD-voters were probably innocent, especially me and Mith.
In her list, leaning innocent: McCaber, me, Mith, Isabellkya
Unsure: Nilp, Shasta, Nerwen, Fea, Boro, Rikae, Lal
Leaning guilty: Nogrod, Sally (which later are her voting options, too)
She states that she doesn't return Boro's trust in her. Confused about Rikae and finds Lal odd.
She says she will take a closer look at Rikae.
Votes Sally.
Apart from the short explanations in her list, she sadly doesn't give much reasons for her suspicions of Nogrod and Sally. The Rikae thing might be interesting to keep in mind.
Things said to/about Brinn yesterDay:
There's Boro's theory in #150. Again, why, if he thought her innocent, did he question her that? As a test?
Rikae thinks Brinn is very innocent. Later she changes her mind and she's her second-best suspect (third-best in the end).
Nogrod goes after her because of her defense against Boro's question.
Boro thinks Brinn's defense was sincere and Nogrod's case forced. Nogrod defends his case.
Lal thinks she will be killed if Brinn is a wolf. Later, she states that she doesn't think Brinn is a wolf.
Nerwen doubts a Brinnwolf would have gone after Kath.
I agree with Nogrod's case. I consider a vote for her but decide against it.
Nilp agrees strongly with Nogrod's case. Votes Gwath because he doesn't see enough support for her.
In the end, Nogrod acknowledges Boro's point and relaxes his suspicion.
I still don't like Boro's part in this very much. Nogrod's case looks over-eager in hindsight, mine and Nilp's agreement stupid - if not worse. Nogrod's and Rikae's back-and-forth on Brinniel looks like the outcome of normal ordo unknowingness.
Why was Brinn killed:
There were others who looked more innocent. There were others who left less trails. I don't think what she said would have made Nogwolf or Sallysawolf think she was the seer. I assume that the wolves picked the most talkative villager who didn't leave trails towards them, but that's a risky conclusion. I can't shake off the feeling that there was something deeper behind it. A case against Rikae could be made but would be a stretch, I think.
Voting:
Mith -> Gwath (semi-random vote with a little reason, neither innocent nor suspicious)
Boro -> Lal (said it then, say it now: terrible reasoning)
Fea -> Boro (consistency in pointlessness?)
Isabell -> Nogrod (consistent with her suspicions, not a very suspicious vote)
Gwath -> Nogrod
McCaber -> Sally (consistent and non-suspicious)
Rikae -> McCaber (I don't really understand her case against him)
Nilp -> Gwath (fuel for a counter-bandwaggon to save fellow Nogwolf?)
Sally -> Nogrod (the suspiciousness of this vote largely depends on Nogrod's role)
Lal -> McCaber (keeping a third option alive)
Brinn -> Sally
Me -> Gwath (this vote looks very ugly if Nogrod turns out to be evil)
Nerwen -> Boro (this vote came out of nowhere - Nerwen, why oh why didn't you say a thing before? I would have preferred to vote for him, too, and Nog surely would have followed... if Boro is really evil, this could have been a secure wolf-on-wolf vote)
Nogrod -> Gwath (self-preservance and consistent with his suspicion)
A lot depends on Nogrod's role here, naturally. If Nogrod dies, it could be useful to have a look at yesterDay's voting again.
Gwath:
Thinks either Boro or Rikae is a wolf, but doesn't know which.
Other than that, he mostly defends himself against Nogrod and suspects him, of course. He votes for him, too.
Very little can be taken from that.
|