Ok,
Mr Swordsman of Shadows (or whatever is the proper translation), you have the honour of being the first one since you're around and talking with me.
Gwathalysis
Day1
#15 nothing of interest
#16 speculates about the rules - I don't quite get his point (a good start for an analysis, isn't it
), but he agrees with
Sam and thinks there might come two traitors every Night in the first three Nights
#30 says to
Kit he wasn't merely restating stuff
#73 expresses confusion over deadline
#86 votes
Kath (no reasoning)
Day2
#93 summarises Day1 voting, doubts that
Nog is a traitor (unless he was saving a fellow
Brinn)
#96 explains his schedules (and kind of explains his vote too)
#117 suspects me for being giddy, wonders how probable it is that there's a newbie wolf
#119 greets newly arrived
Diamond, asks where's
Gaunt
#136 expresses his presence
#139 points out my words could be a sneaky werewolf tactic, wonders if
Groin is trying to use reverse psychology considering himself and
Gollum
#141 agrees (rather shockedly) with
Nogrod that
Groin has been talking almost solely about
Nog during the Day
#178 expresses his presence
#186 votes
Groin, reason: he dropped his suspicion of
Nog as soon as it was questioned by others
Day3
#207 explains his schedules for the Day
#219 apologises for lack of time, votes
Rune because his echoing of
Legate's unfounded suspicion of
Brinn is suspicious
Day4
#260 suspects he must look rather suspicious now, speculates about the number of wws remaining but thinks it's best to concentrate on just finding and lynching one at a time, says he's sick of lynching obvious people, says he may go after the quiet&unobtrusive like
Di or
Golly
#271 replies to me concerning Melkor's alignment
#272 says he thinks I'm right about Melkor being on the Wargs' side and that if
Legate went after
Gollum, he (
G) is probably innocent
#281 asks for clarification for
Gaunt's use of the word "warg"
#284 says his day1 vote for
Kath was random, reconsiders voting
Gollum based on all the
Gollum-
Legate stuff
#300 doesn't like
Gaunt's self-assurance, says he's going to watch him the next Day, voted
Gollum because he has become the default vote of the Day, doesn't even suspect him that much
Overall
Mostly, he actually gives me the imprssion of an ordinary villager. BUT there are a few note-worthy things. He does abnormally lot of "hi I'm here" posts and schedule explanations - he seems a little nervous. And furthermore, I don't like his vote yesterDay. It was too easy - he himself admits it, he doesn't bother to vote properly, but goes with the "default vote". Not very productive and somewhat suspicious. Also, he seems to have been navigating in the tides of this village almost too smoothly, which always makes me raise my eyebrows.
Well, we'll see how he stands compared to
Gaunt and
Di... (I will also examine the connections once I've analysed&summarised all the posts. I'm not sure how much I will get done now, though, it's getting late so I'm going to sleep at some phase...)