[Thinlómien]

If I'm not sleeping, I may as well analyse Gaunt too.

Day1
#25 speculates about the setting, says Sam's scenario of six wargs makes sense

Day2
#125 apologises for lack of participation, pities Sam, doesn't have any suspects
#127 debates on the nature of suspicion, says it would make sense for Nog to have killed Kit because then he'd be removing someone who could succesfully analyse his behaviour
#135 argues that Nogrod would try to play so that it'd be the best for him because he'd understand that the game works the best if everybody does their best to win
#145 is not going to vote Nog - wants more time to watch him and thinks Groin's case against him is flimsy
#147 is suspicious of Nogrod (who criticises silent people and attacks loud people) and thinks Groin suspects Nog for wrong reasons and rather single-mindedly yet necessarily isn't a wolf
#190 votes Groin

Day3
- didn't appear at all -

Day4
#273 apologises/explains absence, doesn't understand Melkor-Manwe thing nor why Shasta died, is inclined to vote Gollum because there have been vague suspicions towards him
#275 asks if it's probable that there are competing pairs of werewolves
#276 continues by asking if it's possible Legate thought Gollum was his archenemy
#279 summarises what has happened this far, presents a theory: two original wolves, Manwe&Melkor joined the game on Night3
#280 based on Kitanna's death, suspect Kath, Gwath and Gollum (she suspected them), thinks Gol and Kath could be fellows
#282 notes that Kath voted Gollum and Gwath voted Kath on Day1, so he would suspect a Gwath-Gollum duo
#283 clarifies his wording about wargs for Gwath
#288 expands on his theory mentiones in post 279, says it was Manwe's work to act as a job and Melkor's job to hunt him down and that now only two original wolves remain, says Nogrod died because he targeted Gollum and Rune died because he came up with some insights that troubled the wolves
#293 suspects Gollum and Gwath are remaining wolves and that either he himself or me will die on Night5, votes Gollum

Overall
He is a smart guy, no doubt, and seems innocentishly helpful and reasonable. But there are a few things that trouble me. He seems to be disturbingly aware about the rules and what happens in the game. It makes me a little suspicious. Also, he concentrates a lot in the rule talk - which is fine and useful, no doubt, but doesn't force him to actually suspect or support people. It troubles me that he voted Groin on Day3 even though he suspected Nogrod more - not that it matters per se as they were both innocent. Just an interesting tidbit.

My brain is in no state for starting to analyse any interactions now, nor will I force it to rank these three people's suspiciousness. That may well wait for tomorrow - I'll go to sleep now and I'll be back here well before the deadline.