View Single Post
Old 12-05-2008, 01:15 AM   #1831
Brinniel
Reflection of Darkness
 
Brinniel's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Polishing the stars. Well, somebody has to do it; they're looking a little bit dull.
Posts: 2,983
Brinniel is a guest of Elrond in Rivendell.Brinniel is a guest of Elrond in Rivendell.Brinniel is a guest of Elrond in Rivendell.
The Votes

Day 1 Rep Votes:

Unknowns-
Greenie: Brinn (2)
Lommy: Ilya
Kath: Lommy
Brinn: Aganzir
Nerwen: didn't vote

Wolves-
Ka: Boromir
morm: Nogrod
Nogrod: Ilya (2)

Day 1 Lynch Votes:

Unknowns-
Brinn: Legate (2)

Wolves-
Nogrod: Gwath

Day 2 Rep Votes:

Unknowns-
Lommy: Nerwen
Nerwen: Lommy
Greenie: morm
Kath: Boromir (2)
Brinn: Kath

Wolves-
morm: Aganzir
Ka: Lommy
Nogrod: Boromir (3)

Day 2 Lynch Votes:

Unknowns-
Kath: Eonwe
Lommy: Eonwe (2)
Nerwen: Eonwe (3)

Wolves-
morm: Nerwen

Day 3 Rep Votes:

Unknowns-
Greenie: morm
Lommy: Shasta
Kath: Nogrod
Brinn: Shasta (2)
Nerwen: Kath (2)

Wolves-
morm: Lommy
Nogrod: Kath
Ka: Greenie

Day 3 Lynch Votes:

Unknowns-
Greenie: the phantom
Kath: Sally
Lommy: Ka

Wolves-
Nogrod: the phantom
morm: Boromir

(the following Day 4 is not very relevant since there were two known wolves and these votes will probably tell us nothing)

Day 4 Rep Votes:

Nerwen: Sally
Kath: Nerwen
Lommy: phantom
Greenie: phantom
Brinn: Boromir

Day 4 Lynch Votes:

Nerwen: morm

Day 5 Rep Votes:

Lommy: Nerwen
Greenie: Kath
Kath: Lommy
Nerwen: Lommy (2)
Brinn: Nerwen (2)

Day 5 Lynch Votes:

Greenie: Sally
Kath: Gwath
Lommy: Sally (2)
Nerwen: Sally (3)

Day 6 Rep Votes:

Greenie: Lommy
Lommy: Kath
Kath: Lommy (2)
Nerwen: Rune
Brinn: Kath (2)

Day 6 Lynch Votes:

Lommy: Gwath
Kath: Gwath (3)

Day 7 Rep Votes:

Greenie: Rune
Lommy: Rune (2)
Brinn: Greenie
Nerwen: Lommy
Kath: didn't vote

Day 7 Lynch Votes:

Greenie: Ilya

Day 8 Rep Votes:

Greenie: Kath
Nerwen: Lommy
Lommy: Kath
Kath: Lommy

-------------------------------------

Known Wolf-on-Wolf rep votes:
morm on Nogrod

Known Wolf-on-Wolf lynch votes:
none

Possible Wolf-on-Wolf rep votes:
Greenie on morm (twice)
Ka on Lommy
Kath on Nogrod
morm on Lommy
Nogrod on Kath
Ka on Greenie

Possible Wolf-on-Wolf lynch votes:
morm on Nerwen

Thoughts:
The question is, how likely is a wolf to vote a fellow as a rep. It happened before, so it's certainly possible. Though I doubt a wolf would be very obvious in their trust in someone. Both morm and Ka voted Lommy...I don't know if two wolves would so openly show such trust in a fellow wolf, which makes me think her more likely innocent. Greenie voted morm twice. It's still possible it was a wolf-on-wolf vote, but then again it'd be awful bold of her. As I stated before about morm's vote to lynch Nerwen, I think at this point it can't really say much to whether she's innocent or not.

In Conclusion:

The following is a suspicion list in order starting from most to least suspicious (I'm not gonna even bother including Gil anymore...with no substance to even analyse him with, I can't see the point).

1) Nerwen
2) Greenie
3) Kath
4) Lommy
__________________
Nolite te bastardes carborundorum
Brinniel is offline   Reply With Quote