The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Gordis · 12-27-2008, 05:45 PM

What was the difference of the situation in the Shire in 3019 from hundreds of similar situations before? - there was none.

For instance, it was quite plain since TA 1050 that the force that occupied Dol Guldur was no good one. From 2060 the Istari believed it was one of the nazgul living there. So, why couldn't they gather all their Maiar band and go finish the bad Necromancer, while he was still weak?

It was also plain since at least 1409 that the King of Angmar was an evil fellow and his removal would be quite beneficial for Arnor, Rivendell and all ME. So- why couldn't the Istari seek him out and vanquish by superior magic?

Same with Castamir. Kill the guy in time and lots of lives would have been saved. Yet not a single attempt at that was made by Gandalf, Radagast and Saruman. They were prohibited to display their Power and openly fight against their foes.

Instead, they had to encourage Elves and Men to unite and oppose evil. I don't think it had ever been easy for Gandalf to send those dear to him forth, often to certain death, while remaining behind the scenes, secure in his Power. Yet it was his doom. The Valar sent him to be the Steward, but neither the King, nor the wet-nurse of the ME peoples. Men, Elves and Hobbits had to take care of their problems themselves.

12-27-2008, 05:45 PM	#19
Gordis Shade of Carn Dûm Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Minas Morgul Posts: 431	What was the difference of the situation in the Shire in 3019 from hundreds of similar situations before? - there was none. For instance, it was quite plain since TA 1050 that the force that occupied Dol Guldur was no good one. From 2060 the Istari believed it was one of the nazgul living there. So, why couldn't they gather all their Maiar band and go finish the bad Necromancer, while he was still weak? It was also plain since at least 1409 that the King of Angmar was an evil fellow and his removal would be quite beneficial for Arnor, Rivendell and all ME. So- why couldn't the Istari seek him out and vanquish by superior magic? Same with Castamir. Kill the guy in time and lots of lives would have been saved. Yet not a single attempt at that was made by Gandalf, Radagast and Saruman. They were prohibited to display their Power and openly fight against their foes. Instead, they had to encourage Elves and Men to unite and oppose evil. I don't think it had ever been easy for Gandalf to send those dear to him forth, often to certain death, while remaining behind the scenes, secure in his Power. Yet it was his doom. The Valar sent him to be the Steward, but neither the King, nor the wet-nurse of the ME peoples. Men, Elves and Hobbits had to take care of their problems themselves. Last edited by Gordis; 12-27-2008 at 05:49 PM.