Manwe. I like blue, sapphires, birds, the wind -- and like him, I have been in the sad position of having a certain naivete about evil come back and bite me in the behind. In particular when it involves members of one's own family.
Ulmo... nice enough guy, but I'm terrified of water. Pretty enough to look at, but only at a safe distance. Oddly enough, a result of having a sibling repeatedly attempt to drown me. Oh, yes, I know how Manwe feels....