[Boromir88]

I do not understand your comment, Boro. I can assure you I would have lynched Aganzir for other reasons than difference in philosophy.~Cailin

Didn't say you would, just saying that's not a reason. You let your actions speak for themselves, Agan, I, and others like "talk" to work things through. Not to be arrogant, I'm not too good finding the first wolf (unless if it's by complete luck), but once one falls, I will say I'm a master at getting the others. So, now that one is gone, the wolves would be wise to get rid of me soon, and singers would be unwise to lynch me.

Fea's associations. I'm only looking at the singers we have no idea about (so this will most likely exclude tp, Agan, and anyone dead). Also, I will be excluding myself, it's your job to analyze me, not mine. Anything I say about myself will probably be biased anyway.

I say we try to host a trip-lynch (against Moddess's wishes) for me, Lariren, Gwath, and Boro. Oh, and Mac, for guilt by association. Oh dear, that's not so triple, is it? Woe are my math skill[z]...~Post 24

Calls for a trip, or not so trip-lynching of Lari, Gwath, Mac, and myself.

In her list in post 116...she says some interesting stuff about sally and Lari.

Sally - Typically seems more innocent than she seems now. So while I don't suggest that she's evil, I do suggest that she might be hiding something.

Lariren - Newbie. She can live a good long while unless she does something that is so obviously wolf-like that it would be foolish not to lynch her.

And then Mac:

Macalaure - A lover of epic proportion, he is willing to travel to the ends of the earth for his True Love. In game, though, he's probably not quite so cool.

Now what was interesting between sally and Mac on Day 1, both tp and Fea were trying to set them up as the two soulmates. Neither of them are, I doubt both are wolves, but it's possible that Fea was going with tp's plan, to help a buddy.

Her comment about Lari looks suspicious too - it's kind of like let her live for a couple days unless she does something completely wolfish, than it's ok to lynch her. To also add on, I remember in the following days, Fea was quick to agree with my statement that Lari made some brilliant analysis. Fea probably knew she was not going to last the entire game as a critic, so it's possible that she could be setting up and innocent Lari. But, also that quick agreement could have been a strategy to push my feelings that Lari was innocent for her excellent analysis.

Lari will be gone for most the day...correct? And based on this, I would in no way propose we lynch her today, just saying I aint giving her the free days anymore, and I'm definitely taking away those complimentary waffles.

Now with Cailin and Gollum, there's no statements of suspicioun/innocent/guilt at all. It's "Oh Gollum, you played in the very first WW! Talk more." And with Cailin is "Eomer taught me a lot."

Her list of who she wants to vote for on Day 1

Which leaves me with

Sally
Ilya
Brinniel
Gwath
Meneltarmacil
Gollum the Great

Ilya, Brinn, and Menel all innocent. That leaves sally, Gwath, and Gollum. It's possibly Fea would put a wolf here at the beginning, but she also had a pretty healthy list of those she wouldn't vote for, and there's no doubt in me, that one critic (if not both) would be in that list:

She says she won't vote for Lari, because she's a newbie. Lots of people were excluding Lari from day 1. But I think some more interesting things is her two pairings:

Shasta or Nog (I need boys around who think in a more streamlined manner than me)

Bowie or Mac (no warning bells a'ringin')

Nog and Bowie, both being innocent. Did she pair up one of her wolf partners (Shasta or Mac) with an innocent?

The rest of the day I believe is all the code talk business, primarily with tp and me. And her vote for Menel, I don't think there's anything there.

...I wonder if I'll have time for Day 2, but just some groupings as far as Fea's interactions.

Lari - Fea discounts her for being a newbie, and we shouldn't lynch her unless she does something entirely wolfish. This raises the suspicion, now that Fea is a critic, but not enough to go on. Plus, with Lari's absense, I want to wait for a response, pressure on, eh?

With sally and Mac she tries to follow tp, and pair them up as soulmates. Mac is a lover, and sally is hiding a secret, but nothing evil. Also with Mac, she pairs him up with an innocent Bowie on who she won't vote for on Day 1. hmm...

With Cailin, and Gollum, she says things about both of them, but nothing regarding suspicions or feelings (that is at least on Day 1). Maybe she didn't want to give anything away?

And with Kath, nothing stands out as far as what Fea has said. Can't determine anything

Fea said at least one thing about everyone on Day 1, so I think it's clear there's interaction there with her other wolf partners, and she is also probably trying to set up innocent people.

Based on the Day 1 stuff, I'm most suspicious of Mac and sally, followed by Lari and Cailin. For the reasons look above.

Edit: cross posted with everyone multiple times