Quote:
Originally Posted by Lalwendë
I wouldn't say so, as it's not created with the same intent in mind.
|
Bethberry bites her tongue to avoid saying anything about the difficulties with authorial intention.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Morth
Not wishing to sound like a chauvinist, but I found Mists of Avalon dreadfully boring and devoid of humor. I prefer T.H. White's retelling of the Arthurian cycle in The Once and Future King. Mary Stewart's Merlin series (The Crystal Cave, The Hollow Hills, etc.) is interesting in parts, but is rather somber, and tends to meander later on in the series.
|
Since this has been quoted liberally by several Downers, I might as well chime in to see if we can set a Downs record for most quoted post comment.
Also, not wanting to sound like a chauvinist, I too found MoA heavy going, in much the same way I dislike most of Atwood. The dogmatics are just too, well, dogmatic and I can take only so much knocking on my skull before my reading skills are numbed senseless.
Have never read Mary Stewarts' Merlin series so I'll take a look at them and maybe even a relook at TH White, as it's been years and years. . .
But for new current fantasy, I found
The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss quite fascinating, especially from the perspective of a Tolkien read. The debt is there, but this is no mere pale imitation.