Non-
Dury voters:
Rikae:
Votes for
Greenie. I explained it at the time... nothing else to say. She's the best suspect I had at the moment (as for the comment about being tired of
Mac being a baddie, I was trying to explain why I might be inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt more than others are – because I want him to be innocent).
Agan:
Votes for
Mac with reasons that seem pretty rational (suspicious comments he made, not wanting to vote for me or
Lommy, her other suspects, thinking there is some connection between us,
Mac, and/or
Nog... although I don't really understand how she thought
Nog was connected). I don't see anything particularly suspicious here.
Greenie:
Votes
Nog.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Greenie
In addition to his weird Golly-vote, that Dury thing just doesn't make any sense. It looks something like a crafted case that has failed (deliberately or not) to take into account a very significant factor which is, as Rikae already pointed out, the fact that Dury's role was mysterious cloaked figure or something like that. Dunno, somehow Noggins' behavior makes me think he's a wolf who's trying just a bit too hard.
|
Makes sense (well, I'm not sure what she means with the
Gollum-vote thing), but perhaps a tad easy. Would an evil
Nog make such a huge error? I didn't think so at the time, which is why I tried to correct him, instead of trying to lynch him.
Menel:
Votes
Mac, with kind of a strange explanation (saying Mac and I want to distract the village). It's more or less typical
Menel-posting, though.
Lommy:
Votes
Agan because of her style and personal reasons. Not the greatest reasoning; perhaps too bad to be bad, if you know what I mean (unless the whole
Agan-fixation is an attempt to avoid attracting attention and antagonizing other players...).
Brinniel:
Votes
Fea, after saying everyone is going to cross-post. Very innocent looking vote, but could be one of those of a wolf using a
Fea-sacrifice to look good, for just that reason. Her posts, however, feel sincere.
Durelin:
Votes
Mac. Known innocent, trying to save herself, nothing to comment on there.
Berry:
Makes a point of not joining the
Durelin-lynching mob, votes
Mac. Could indeed be a wraith trying to make himself look good, if someone is.
Did not vote:
Sally,
Leggy,
Nerwen.
Conclusions:
The only ones who could be taking advantage of being on the right side of the
Dury lynch are
Berry and
Brinn, and
Brinn, especially, doesn't look like it. There are some slightly suspicious things in the other votes, but nothing extremely so. The non-voters, of course, are in position to really slip under the radar and shouldn't be allowed to do so (the only one of them who looks suspicious to me right now is
Sally, though).
It does seem like an evil
Fea would make the following people worth more scrutiny:
Lari
Mac
Beregond
Mira
Rune
But as I think we can be more sure about
Fea than any of those, she remains our best lynch for toDay.
(To
Legate: if it were anyone but
Fea, I'd agree with you on ignoring her... but I don't trust the village to be able to ignore
Fea, nor do I think we can be at all sure she's only a cobbler).