Well, I've finished my chart. Not sure how useful it is, but I've attached it if anyone cares to have a look. Basically, I went through all the posts looking for things
Sally and
Brinn said about everyone and vice versa suggesting that person was not a wolf (or, in
Mac's case, that he was or was not a cobbler). I put the post numbers in the chart (many of these have been mentioned by others, but I wanted a handy reference - I was looking for strong suspicions of an endangered wolf (or possible wolf) mostly, and also such things as forgetting someone. I didn't look for "wolfish" things because those are too often misleading, in my experience.
I also listed everyone's votes for the first three days and their stance on various controversial issues that have arisen over the course of the game.
My conclusions (as far as the old wraith goes):
RED:
Mira - has nothing standing against her being a wraith, plus a suspicious-looking vote on Day 2 speaking against her. She and the known wolves pretty much ignored each other. Could well be a flying-under-the-radar wraith.
Mac - Both known wolves defend him after Night 2 (when he would have sent his own name, if Ferny), although
Sally wanted him lynched on Day 1.
ORANGE:
Legate - Has suprisingly little standing against him being a wraith, especially if
Mac is innocent or if he decided to sacrifice him. Could also be Frodo. On second glance, Day 1 posts look like he was trying to give advice to Ferny.
Er.... PEACH
Aganzir - Also has little against her wraithishness or Frodoliness. Initial wishywashy reaction to
Lommy vs.
Brinn looks bad. Jump on possible
Mac-cobbler looks better if he is one, since she votes him on Day 2, when she would have probably known if he was Ferny.
YELLOW
Rune - Lots of fighting with
Brinn, almost looks wolf-on-wolf, but pretty serious if it is (with
Brinn almost getting lynched).
Menel - Votes for
Mac every time, which looks good if
Mac is bad, doesn't tell us much if
Mac is good. Weirdly trusts
Brinn at first. Nothing really against his wraithishness (unless
Mac is Ferny).
CHARTREUSE
Lari - is only somewhat suspicious, and less so if
Mac is Ferny.
GREEN
Greenie -
Brinn appears to have tried to scapegoat her, which speaks in her favor.
Berry - If
Mac is guilty,
Berry is probably innocent. His reaction to my fake seer-reveal looks pretty innocent, too.
Nerwen - There are reasons she wouldn't be a wolf with each known wolf, innocentish vote on Day 1.
Rikae - Not on the chart, because why would you trust me to analyze myself?
