Ok, wow, so I come back on and see like 3 new pages, lots has happened.
So I've skimmed through everything and got the basic gist of what's happened. I'm leaning towards believing Rikae (since I am a simple white pawn, not the "real" WQ or a baddie), and I think I have a theory as to how it could all make sense. I'm not sure if this has been said yet or not.
So, since the good Ranger can protect from people at Night, perhaps the bad Ranger protects people from being lynched? That would explain Izzy's mysterious survival, and also prove that she is a baddie. So the evil Ranger protected her, she didn't get lynched, and enjoyed the mass confusion it caused. (It's possible cause Shasta never really clarified the way an evil Ranger would work) That would make Sally the cobbler, trying to get the WQ(who I'm thinking really is Rikae) lynched, and pave the way for the baddie victory.
Ahh, I need to think about this, I'll be back soon and probably change my vote.
X'posted with a few, will post again once I see what phantom has to say. (don't take too long please, I'm getting tired
)