Hey, that was fun! Aside from the apparent masterpieces art-wise, I find
Lommy's graffited Nazgul and
wilwa's CM incredibly cuuute

Although what I liked really the most was the portrayal of Bombur the Geomethric

(but also the square-shaped characters). I just loved Form's picture, though, and Eönwë's consequent sentence ("Saruman of Ye Blacke Staffe commandeth..."

) And I also like
Hookbill's original pic a lot.
By the way, when looking at it, I found it interesting that on my picture, Radagast reappeared again (even though he was already not in the text anymore by then).