The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Hurt and Heal VI: Weapons and Other Oddities

Aganzir · 05-13-2009, 04:40 PM

I don't see a reason to limit the number of seconds, Lalaith. I trust people can control themselves enough not to misuse the voting power they've been given.

Given the number of weapons we have thus far, I think we could do with just weapons & armour on this round. Therefore I'm excluding stuff like the Girdle of Melian, Bombadil's boots (which, in my opinion, are rather other items than armour), the rings etc from the list. However if you think some of them should be included, speak up.

As for Tuor's dragon suggestions, I rather didn't take them because they are very different weapons from the rest. If there is considerable opposition to this, though, I may consider otherwise.

I second Belthronding & the Morgul blades and nominate Ringil & Angrist.

Oh by the way - do we want Anglachel, Gurthang or both?

Seconded weapons:

Grond (Morgoth's)
Black Arrow
Aeglos
Anguirel
Anglachel
Aranrúth
Glamdring
The Barrow-Blades
Belthronding
Morgul Blades

Pending for approval:

Sting
Grond II
Narsil
Andúril
The Dragon Helm
Ringil
Angrist

05-13-2009, 04:40 PM	#13
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	I don't see a reason to limit the number of seconds, Lalaith. I trust people can control themselves enough not to misuse the voting power they've been given. Given the number of weapons we have thus far, I think we could do with just weapons & armour on this round. Therefore I'm excluding stuff like the Girdle of Melian, Bombadil's boots (which, in my opinion, are rather other items than armour), the rings etc from the list. However if you think some of them should be included, speak up. As for Tuor's dragon suggestions, I rather didn't take them because they are very different weapons from the rest. If there is considerable opposition to this, though, I may consider otherwise. I second Belthronding & the Morgul blades and nominate Ringil & Angrist. Oh by the way - do we want Anglachel, Gurthang or both? Seconded weapons: Grond (Morgoth's) Black Arrow Aeglos Anguirel Anglachel Aranrúth Glamdring The Barrow-Blades Belthronding Morgul Blades Pending for approval: Sting Grond II Narsil Andúril The Dragon Helm Ringil Angrist __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle.