Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Zil
The signs appear to point to a Mutineer Mac and a Conspirator Gwath.
With Rikae's vote for Gwath, it was a reasonable assumption for the mutineers that he would indeed be her pick for the Night as well. She'd been voicing some serious questions about Mac at the end of Day 4, and what better time to take her out than while her attention was focused on a (relative) innocent?
|
How does this make sense? First you say
Mac is a mutineer, then you refer to him when saying
Rikae's attention was focused on a relative innocent. And none of it explains why
Gwath is a conspirator.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mac
And why do you say that you know it?
|
Because I can read your thoughts.
No, not really, I don't know why, but I'm just dead certain you're evil. I have a gut-feeling and I have reasons, and of course when I'm firmly in the belief that you're a mutineer I can explain everything from that persepctive (so criticism towards me is always welcome). But really, I'm just sure of it. I will apologise greatly after the game if I was wrong here, but really, you're just so evil it hurts.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mac
Can you give me a non-vague reason why you are so certain of me?
|
Yes, sir. I was thinking of making a post that explains why I think you're evil all in one post, and I will make it as soon as possible, but before that I won't repeat my arguments.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
For someone who says she doesn't scheme, you sound capable at being able to sniff possible one's out. I wonder how?
|
My refrainment (sp?) from scheming does not mean that I'd be unacquainted with or uncapable of such art.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Rikae
It's possible you're 11 with 6 evil, which would mean you've already lost, if the baddies can but coordinate their efforts (not to be a morbid voice from beyond the grave... in the Barrow Downs, no less... but I just thought I should point that out). Even without the cobblers - if all the wolves are alive, you have one more day. DOOM!!!! REPENT!!!
|
I'm optimistic enough to think we have taken down one of them already (
Sally probably) but in case you're right this is not the time for lynching a ghost.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Lommy is giving me the creeps right now. She's, well how should one say it, careless or jubilant - and confident? (if all the mutineers are alive she has reason to be jubilant and confident)
|
I'm far from careless, not jubilant until this game is over (and not even then if we're going to lose like it looks like) but I'm confident. I'm confident that
Mac is a mutineer. And you, on the other hand, were probably a cobbler and are now trying to cause chaos by pretending to be sensible. (Suggesting a
Greenie lynch and ignoring all the counter-arguments is about the most cobblerish thing you can do.)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Jog my memory, please (it's late here in the Antipodes): what has Kath done? You suspect her, Rikae suspects her... and I can't remember a single thing she's said this game.
|
Nothing. A few lists. I think she voted
Annu at some point. That's it. But I'm scared of her because she's always so sneaky and I have no way to catch her now that the roles are hidden! And I have come to think of quite many people in this crew as innocents, so I don't have much possible mutineers on my list except
Kath and that's why I'm wary of her and looking forward to seeing what she'll say or do. And like I said, some of my suspicion is rather irrational "it must be her" stuff.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sally
She's often a Night kill, so why's she still around? Heh, I was going to point this out yesterDay but was busy until it was too late to do anything toward a Kath lynch anyway.
|
What kind of logic is this?? I tell y'all,
Sally sure wasn't totally innocent.
edit: xed with the last four