Quote:
|
Boro -> autume - Boro, why is "A lot of commentary mixed in with a couple jokes" suspicious?~Mac
|
Why do you think
autume is guilty then?
But seriously for Day 1, I can't think of a better reason yet to vote for someone than besides a player who just comments on the activity, not really offering an opinion, and tries some jokes to look nice (it's the fair to be wary of, not someone who will call a rat a rat). Sometimes I'm pretty cheerful, if there's a good lot of posting, but I called
Inzil a commentator last game because that's what he was doing and only offering his opinion on completely irrelevant matters like whether a wolf would openly like blood or not. I got the same commenting feel from
autume's first couple posts (and after the point when the true suspicions were supposed to start) - and I mentally graded her list a "D-''
...oops I just made a joke.
I was going to analyze the votes, but seeing as from the morning I missed
Mac's posting of votes and analysis, all I can really say is for the most part I agree with it, but will point out the differences...
None of the
sally voters strikes 'wolf on wolf' to me, so I'm not sure why there are suspicions around
Nerwen? She was pretty set on either
Fea or
sally right when they first voted for her. The only reason her vote came when it did, is because she was in a position where it was reasonable to withhold her vote in case she had to safe herself. Plus...well she got a wolf, a wolf she suspected almost immediately.
Nienna looks the most innocent, for that end of the day bit with
sally. When
sally first voted for
Nienna, I thought she never retracted, therefor it shouldn't count and wondered if
sally was going down in 'style' to try and protect a wolf-
Nienna. However, based on what sally said and Lari counted it for a tie, than I'm assuming
sally was purely voting for
Nienna to try and save herself, not as some sacrificial trick to help
Nienna. Does that make any sense? I'm afraid it makes sense in my head, but out on the screen it might not.
I'm worried about
Formendacil's vote for
Hakon, more so than
Mac. It could be genuine confusion, caused by
Form joining us late and trying to read through the day. But I don't know that rushing could also just be a wolf-
Form joining in late, seeing sally in trouble and trying to figure out what to do to save her. I want to hear more from
Form about his vote, he should now have plenty of time and not be rushed by the DL.