Well I must join those who were surprised with
Hakon not being a wolf...
BUt just few things for starters.
First of all what should we make of the following?
THe last guard-vote tally was given by
Stally at 5 minutes before the DL and it stood like this (leaders at the moment bolded by me):
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sally
Guard:
Nerwen-->Nienna
Greenie-->Boro
Sally-->Nienna (2)
Wilwa-->Nienna (3)
Boro-->Nilp
Hakon-->Nilp (2)
Nienna-->Sally (awwww, thanks!)
|
After that, at
.59
Pitchwife voted to guard
Nerwen (who died during the Night)
.59
Brinn voted to guard me
.00 I voted to guard
Nienna (because I thought her more safe to us than
Nilp and had a chance to try and make sure she got protected)
Now you might already see where I'm getting at...
If you ask me both
Pitchie's and
Brinn's guard-votes look odd - and not in a good way. At the last minute they both threw in new candidates even if it was quite clear we had to choose between
Nienna and
Nilp.
But what does it then mean? I don't know.
I could see a wolf-
Brinn throwing that kind of "feel good / look good" guard-vote to me and later when I'm dead she could say she trusted me as much as to protect me earlier.
I could as well - or even better - see a wolf-
Pitchie to vote to guard
Nerwen with the: "Obviously a good choice, or do I have to explain more?" and then killing her during the Night. That would be classical indeed but still possible.
I'm not too confident both of these cases hold but I'd be surprised if they both were wrong. But they both show a kind of lack of interest of who gets protected which I always find lupine.
On the subject of
McCaber then.
I find it especially suspicious that he said we should lynch
Legate (we can afford it), then backs off from it avoiding the bandwagon - and then emerges as one keeping the moral highground not being one of the lynchers. Managing to stay away from
Hakonwagon - and not only staying away but claiming it openly of not liking it, would fit a wishing-to-look-good wolf's profile pretty well. The pre-explanation of the wolf-tactics on Day1 looks interesting as well as he hasn't otherwise made such good points about the general tactics or possibilities...
So there seems to be reasons to suspect him and maybe even to lynch him. The thing I don't like here is that were he a wolf he might be a bit more vocal and involved. But I'm not sure.
Does anyone remember who was that one who went it all through being a real submarine and won the whole thing? Was it
McCaber or was it someone else?
Xyzzy perhaps?
FYI:
Greenie &
Lommy are staying over at my place today so
Greenie & me will not be flood-posting toDay...