Quote:
Originally Posted by The Saucepan Man
Funny how meta-reasoning works. Despite being fully aware that the roles were assigned randomly, my mind refused to accept the notion that Roa and Nog could be Wolves together.
|
I really thought the fact that we weren't at each others' throats would really tip everyone off.
Quote:
|
Well, I agreed with your reasoning (although it was, of course, in our interests for Wolves and Bear to be at each others' throats from the outset). But, to be fair, you were not helped by Hakon here. I would be interested to hear from him whether he did dream of you. But, even if not, I presume that the Wolves thought that he did. Is that right Wolves?
|
Actually,
Boromir was a lucky kill for us. We just wanted to get rid of a vocal and strong player, and lay false trails along the way. We had no inkling that
Boromir was the bear. I was pulling for you, BTW.
Quote:
I'd be interested to hear why you didn't kill us, then. Was it purely the threat of our revenge kill, or did you want to preserve the option of teaming up with us? I did wonder when I saw that sally was not a Wolf whether you might decide to kill one of us that Night and take your chances. I also thought that, if Nog was a Wolf, he might be reluctant to do a deal, thinking it unsporting. 
|
The unsporting thing was why we didn't kill you on Night 2. And as I said, there really wasn't a back and forth about working with you. Really, the reason we didn't kill you was the odds. We had better odds with you alive than with you dead.
Quote:
|
Roa - You fooled me with what looked like genuine reactions twice - first when you backed off after suspecting me so strongly on Day 1 and then again with your reaction to our reveal, which I thought totally genuine. Was that all acting, or was there an element of frustration there? Later, I became increasingly convinced of your Wolfishness, particularly when Fea pointed out to me that the Wolves had a great opportunity to get you lynched on Day 3 and failed to take it.
|
Had I been an innocent, the frustration would have been real. As a wolf, however, I was only intrigued to see how it played out. I admit, I hoped that more people would be on the "Yeah, let's lynch Fea!" idea.
Though I assure you, if we had one more Nightly kill, it would have been one of you.