The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Nienna · 12-02-2009, 01:19 PM

Shasta

YesterDay

46. Summarized the Day: Boro v. Roa on ‘Reasonableness’

47. In character but the deadline is weird for him

68. Calls Morsul wishy-washy and fence sitting

137. Points against Nog for being definitive in his suspicion against Roa, point against Eomer for subtly backing Nog up, point for Roa for her reaction to Nog, point against Nog for wild accusations on flimsy evidence, point for Roa… not sure why, point for Nog for giving a more accurate representation of what Boro said, 3 points against Nog for bringing up something her shouldn’t really bring up anyway, point against Roa for the Nog-Cobbler theory because it’s a stretch. Nog has now cleared up some ambiguities and he’d rather not vote for him, he won’t vote Roa but would be willing to vote Eomer.

This is an interesting post… I think it is a good analysis of the Nog/Roa thing giving them each criticisms

142-3. Clarifying for Nog

171. Votes for Zil, would rather not see Mac or Mnemo go

I voted for him for the same reason so I cannot fault it.

ToDay:

220. Isn’t really buying Boro’s ‘this isn’t how I play as a wolf’ act, didn’t vote for Zil because Mac suggested it, defends not throwing away his vote

Seems reasonable (do with that what you will)

234. Notices a weird phrasing by Brinn, Newen’s vote was mostly out of nowhere, at the last moment, and would have sealed Mac’s fate. He doesn’t trust Nerwen

I disagree with the point about Brinn’s phrasing as it made perfect sense to me. I do think that Nerwen’s vote was a little dodgy.

256. Agrees that his point against Brinn might be a bit of a stretch

In Summary: I’m not sure why he was ringing alarm bells for me… he seems to be making reasonable points, his thing about Brinn was a stretch but he knows that… I’m going to just have to keep watching him.

Edit: Crossed.

12-02-2009, 01:19 PM	#341
Nienna Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: School Posts: 642	Shasta YesterDay 46. Summarized the Day: Boro v. Roa on ‘Reasonableness’ 47. In character but the deadline is weird for him 68. Calls Morsul wishy-washy and fence sitting 137. Points against Nog for being definitive in his suspicion against Roa, point against Eomer for subtly backing Nog up, point for Roa for her reaction to Nog, point against Nog for wild accusations on flimsy evidence, point for Roa… not sure why, point for Nog for giving a more accurate representation of what Boro said, 3 points against Nog for bringing up something her shouldn’t really bring up anyway, point against Roa for the Nog-Cobbler theory because it’s a stretch. Nog has now cleared up some ambiguities and he’d rather not vote for him, he won’t vote Roa but would be willing to vote Eomer. This is an interesting post… I think it is a good analysis of the Nog/Roa thing giving them each criticisms 142-3. Clarifying for Nog 171. Votes for Zil, would rather not see Mac or Mnemo go I voted for him for the same reason so I cannot fault it. ToDay: 220. Isn’t really buying Boro’s ‘this isn’t how I play as a wolf’ act, didn’t vote for Zil because Mac suggested it, defends not throwing away his vote Seems reasonable (do with that what you will) 234. Notices a weird phrasing by Brinn, Newen’s vote was mostly out of nowhere, at the last moment, and would have sealed Mac’s fate. He doesn’t trust Nerwen I disagree with the point about Brinn’s phrasing as it made perfect sense to me. I do think that Nerwen’s vote was a little dodgy. 256. Agrees that his point against Brinn might be a bit of a stretch In Summary: I’m not sure why he was ringing alarm bells for me… he seems to be making reasonable points, his thing about Brinn was a stretch but he knows that… I’m going to just have to keep watching him. Edit: Crossed. __________________ Puddle! Puddle!