Pitchalysis
(I don't know how to link posts, so forgive me. They're numbered, though. I skipped over all the banter.)
#27 (
Mac) - "
Pitch gives me an innocent feel, for some reason." Interesting, considering he's said nothing but banter up to this point.
#35 (
Boro) - Clarifies a suspicion of
Pitch based on a Captain Obvious moment.
#51 (
Pitch) - "I agree about not lynching reasonable people, especially not those who have made an effort to turn this into a serious discussion - which would be Roa, Mnemo and Boro, most notably.
"
Roa left the game as an innocent and
Mnemo's a dead wolf. What does this say about
Boro, I wonder?
#57 (
Mac) - Mentions that
Pitch's comment about the
Boro-reasonableness-versus-unreasonableness debate "might be" suspicious.
#58 (
Lommy) - Is inclined to like
Pitch for being agreeable and sensible, but wonders if he's not
too agreeable. A rather nice fence-sit, in my opinion.
#91 (
Nog) - Calls
Pitch "one of the most dangerous wolves there are" because of his tendency to slip under the radar.
#102 (
Pitch) - Thinks
Boro ought to get a break, as he's "stirring the pot". Also considers him to be dodgy (I'm nullifying the obvious qualifier here).
#106 (
Pitch) - Notes
Mac's use of double standards.
#108 (
Mnemo) - "Might" vote for
Pitch because he feels a little "off" (says the same for
Inzil). Typical wolvish distancing.
#112 (
Mac) - Brings
Pitch down from "innocent" to "unsure". Interesting.
#120 (
Pitch) - Mentions that
Morsul looks rather innocent.
#127 (
Pitch) - Says a lot without saying much. Notes that
Eomer makes more good points than anyone else mentioned in the post (
Lommy,
Greenie,
Brinn, and myself). Also notes that
Nerwen seems to be acting differently than usual... and then qualifies it.
#128 (
Mnemo) - More wolvish distancing. Says she'll vote for
Pitch or
Inzil.
#133 (
Eomer) - Puts
Pitch in the "Will probably vote for one of" category, along with six other people.
#139 (
Mac) - Puts
Pitch (and
Mnemo!) in the "I would like to avoid voting" category. For a
Mac who's won by sacrificing his wolf partners, this seems strange for a
Macwolf to do, but I wouldn't put it past him (oh no, qualifying is becoming contagious!)
#150 (
Pitch) - Pushes
Nogrod as having the secret role. Why?
#155 (
Mac) - Flipflops on
Pitch again, seeing him as innocent.
#158 (
Nogrod) - Notes that both
Inzil and
Pitch both are being "careful".
#162 (
Pitch) - votes
Mac for "double standards, general slipperyness, plus the flip-flopping
Zil pointed out."
#192 (
Mnemo) - More distancing. "I need to take a closer look at
Pitch and
Inzil today."
#198 (
Pitch) - A few things. First,
Pitch doesn't get
Boro's comment about
Inzil and
Mac not being gifted. Doesn't want to assume anything about
Inzil and
Mac. Secondly, interacts with
Mac, wanting to know about his feelings about
Inzil (also mentions
Mnemo here).
#205 (
Mnemo - Subtly backs up
Pitch on the subject of gifteds not necessarily revealing when up for a lynch. I wonder if they weren't setting each other up for a reveal of some kind, or at least giving themselves fodder to contest a reveal later should it happen.
#207 (
Nogrod) - Calls
Pitch's vote for
Mac into question.
#213 (
Pitch) - Says something I find amusing, in hindsight: "I rather prefer staying out of Day 1 bandwagons." Hence his vote for
Mac (third of four). Right.
#217 (
Mac) - Says he would like to take a closer look at
Pitch and
Mnemo. Interesting...
#233 (
Nogrod - "
Mac and
Pitch are not both wolves." I have a problem with statements like this. They're far too absolute.
#273 (
Lommy) - "
Nogrod has quite good points against
Pitchie, but I still wonder about him too."
Lommy, when you say "him", which "him" are you referring to?
Pitch or
Nog? Also, has both
Mnemo and
Pitch in her "Leaning guilty" group.
#274 (
Mac) - Uncomfortable with suspecting
Pitch if other people are going to do the same. A rather odd comment.
#313 (
Mac) - Grants
Pitch more innocence.
Mac, you flip-flop on
Pitch a lot.
#334 (
Eomer) - Notes that he didn't want to vote
Pitch (or
Brinn or
Lommy).
#343 (
Pitch) - Starts to jump on me for my vote for
Inzil, butting into a conversation between
Morsul and
Nienna.
#345 (
Morsul) - Agrees with
Pitch against me.
#350 (
Lommy) - Thinks there's something fishy about
Pitch.
#356 (
Nogrod) - "Some of
Pitch's posting looks odd and over-careful."
#359 (
Sally) - Puts
Pitch in her "Possible wolves" column. I think this is the first time she's even mentioned
Pitch.
#360 (
Pitch) - Notes that voting to save someone by giving someone else their second or third vote doesn't look innocent (referring to
Nienna and myself). Also thinks my vote for
Nerwen was "voting those who're too reasonable". Um, what?
#363 (
Wilwa) - First time she's mentioned
Pitch, calls him "iffy" after a quick skim and might vote for him. Interesting. Notes that her vote will probably be between
Boro and
Pitch.
#372 (
Nogrod) - Considering a
Pitch vote for being too nice.
#381 (
Wilwa) - "I've decided it would be best for me to stick with
Boro as previously stated." Is this a wolf not wanting to be accused of a wolf-on-wolf vote?
#386 (
Sally) - "
Pitch: another bad vibe, to be honest;" Interesting.
#395 (
Pitch) - Clearly defends
Mac against
Morsul which I find odd.
#416 (
Bes) - First time
Bes has really mentioned
Pitch. Suspects
Mac,
Pitch, and
Nogrod all equally.
#426 (
Eomer) - Puts "innocent?" by
Pitch because of his vote for
Mnemo.
#427 (
Pitch) - Refutes
Eomer and says his vote was safe. (
Eomer clarifies in the next post - he meant his Day 1 vote). Qualifies the rest of his conclusions.
#438 (
Nogrod) -
Mnemo's vote for
Pitch flips what he thinks about
Pitch - "more innocent than not".
Pitch looks rather good for his vote for
Mnemo.
#440 (
Eomer) - Has
Pitch firmly in the "Innocent" column. Interesting.
#444 (
Pitch) - Flip-flops his stance on my vote for
Nerwen Day 1, even though he's replying to something
Nogrod said about someone completely different.
#451 (
Pitch) - "Of the
Lottie-votes, I'd say
Brinn looks the most innocent to me."
#460 (
Mac) - Vacillates on
Pitch before finally finding him innocent on account of the wolves' kill choice of
Inzil.
#461 (
Wilwa) - As a side affect of her
Mnemo analysis, thinks
Pitch to be innocent.
#476 (
Nerwen) - Seems to be a general consensus; thinks
Mnemo's vote for
Pitch was unlikely to be wolf-on-wolf.
#481 (
Mac) - Feels quite good about
Pitch, in both situations.
#483 (
Lommy) -
Pitch is "probably innocent". Dang, he certainly had it made before
Lottie's reveal.
#497 (
Wilwa) - Is suddenly wary of
Pitch again, mostly after being called on it by
Boro. A flustered wolf? Immediately puts him in the "most uneasy" column.
#517 (
Pitch) - Finds
Bes's vote for
Lottie suspicious.
#518 (
Sally) - Agrees with
Pitch regarding
Bes. I dunno, such stout backing up doesn't lead me to think wolf-on-wolf -
Sally's smarter than that.
#519 (
Boro) - Applaud's
Pitch's lack of agreeableness in posting an alternate perception, that
Lottie was an attempt to save
Mnemo.
#538 (
Pitch) - Retracts his earlier statement of
Brinn's innocence, and tries to push
Lottie to dream of
Bes. To me, this points towards
Bes's innocence.
#539 (
Lommy) - Is quite convinced that
Pitch is an ordo.
---------------
Surely not all,
Mac. I analyzed those who interacted with [b]Pitch[b], too.
Edit: Formatting.