Reading through the thread I was quite amazed of the fast and easy "
Lommy-wagon" - even if people suspecting her had suspected her earlier as well. But it looked really bad.
Which brought me to this:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thinlómien
Loslote you being a known innocent does not mean thta you don't need to reason your votes or use your brains. 
|
Now let's pause for a moment.
Lottie called her role as the "
Birthday dreamer"
Now please veterans help me out (
Lommy &
Boro I think have played long enough) or those who have read the really old games...
But wasn't a "birthday dreamer" a person who got to dream of someone on a certain pre-given Night (like Night 3 or 4) - and then
got the role of the one s/he dreamt?!!!
That is the birthday -part of it: as a present that person may take the new role (I don't remember whether it was compulsory to take that role or whether there was a choice involved).
Enedwaith...
Feel free to suspect me that I'm trying to out our only "known innocent", but I'm pretty serious. It is a real concern to me at least now that I remembered the nature of that role, as it had been. Not only because it would mean we have actually three wolves left and not just two, but also that one of them might lie down in front of us trusted by everyone.
If I was a wolf and the stuff I say was just my trick on you, please consider would I then try to voice this concern this openly? I know some of you jump on me saying: he's trying to speak against
Lottie once more and she must be innocent. But I have felt the whole
Lottie-thing being odd all the time. Was it
Wilwa who said that what an anticlimax to have a once dreaming seer as the secret role... I agree. And looking at what she does doesn't make me think of her any more innocentish.
A birthday dreamer - old-school way - would be a neutralish role in the beginning as that person could dream of anyone; gifted or wolf or ordo...
Why did they sacrifice
Pitchie then? A good question... Maybe there was a ruling that if she found a wolf he should be revealed as not to make the game too uneven (already four wolves in the beginning and then this to put people off the track even more)?
I'm not sure about this... well how could I be? But consider, especially you who are familiar with the "Birthday dreamer".
Okay, now to make myself a dinner... just had to vent this out.