The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Bes · 12-11-2009, 03:42 PM

Without quoting, lots of people were apparently surprised by my vote yesterday. I really don't see why: Yes, I originally thought the Birthday Dreamer role turning Lottie into a wolf seemed awkward and out of place with Lottie's behavior. I also then found and posted evidence to the contrary, and read other people's takes on the situation before coming to a decision.

Sure, we were wrong and Lottie wasn't a wolf. We know this now, whee and such. That doesn't change that I had every reason at the start to think that Lottie wasn't a wolf, and after I had pretty good reasons to change my mind, with citation to boot. That citation was even backed up, using references to the role in yet another game. After that, whether or not the game started on Legate's birthday came into debate, some people saying yes and others no. Lottie was accused of being a wolf, looked like she was going down, and suddenly I was all suspicious for 'defending' her (selective reading? I guess so.) What choice was there but to vote for her? I mean, barring a throw away vote that had nothing to do with what had happened that day, or voting for Nog who at the time seemed to be making sense and had no other votes.

Anyway, why ARE you so emotional about the vote, Shasta? Is it just because you wanted Lommie to get lynched, or is there something else going on here?

All of that said, Nog looks odd to me now. It was a long while back, but I've shown that he knew exactly what the Birthday Dreamer role usually is before this game, but he acted like it was some sudden revelation yesterDay. It could be nothing, but it looks at least slightly suspicious now that we know Lottie didn't become a wolf I think.

Also, I bet I'll cross with a few, as usual.

Edit: Crossed with Shasta, Boro, Shasta, Nog, Shasta and Nog. I feel like I type slow now.

12-11-2009, 03:42 PM	#1037
Bes Animated Skeleton Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Virginia Posts: 42	Without quoting, lots of people were apparently surprised by my vote yesterday. I really don't see why: Yes, I originally thought the Birthday Dreamer role turning Lottie into a wolf seemed awkward and out of place with Lottie's behavior. I also then found and posted evidence to the contrary, and read other people's takes on the situation before coming to a decision. Sure, we were wrong and Lottie wasn't a wolf. We know this now, whee and such. That doesn't change that I had every reason at the start to think that Lottie wasn't a wolf, and after I had pretty good reasons to change my mind, with citation to boot. That citation was even backed up, using references to the role in yet another game. After that, whether or not the game started on Legate's birthday came into debate, some people saying yes and others no. Lottie was accused of being a wolf, looked like she was going down, and suddenly I was all suspicious for 'defending' her (selective reading? I guess so.) What choice was there but to vote for her? I mean, barring a throw away vote that had nothing to do with what had happened that day, or voting for Nog who at the time seemed to be making sense and had no other votes. Anyway, why ARE you so emotional about the vote, Shasta? Is it just because you wanted Lommie to get lynched, or is there something else going on here? All of that said, Nog looks odd to me now. It was a long while back, but I've shown that he knew exactly what the Birthday Dreamer role usually is before this game, but he acted like it was some sudden revelation yesterDay. It could be nothing, but it looks at least slightly suspicious now that we know Lottie didn't become a wolf I think. Also, I bet I'll cross with a few, as usual. Edit: Crossed with Shasta, Boro, Shasta, Nog, Shasta and Nog. I feel like I type slow now.